Full Story Broken trust: why police are failing to learn from their own mistakes
Nov 17, 2025
In a compelling dialogue, Kate Persina, a former Queensland Police detective and whistleblower, and Cameron Harsley, a former Deputy Commissioner, dive into systemic failures within the police regarding domestic violence cases. They discuss shocking allegations of a cover-up, the mishandling of critical evidence, and the alarming consequences faced by victims like Gail and Cardell. They critically address the impact of policing culture on community trust and highlight the urgent need for accountability and genuine reform to protect vulnerable individuals.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Woman's Recording Proved Critical Evidence
- Gail Karen recorded her own fatal attack and the attacker saying he read what she told the coppers.
- Police released the alleged attacker the same night and did not initially seize her recorder, delaying crucial evidence.
Repeated Help-Seeking Still Led To Death
- Carter (Cardell) Lomas repeatedly sought help and was found dead in a car boot while seven months pregnant.
- Despite 24 interactions with agencies, police and services failed to protect her from a known violent offender.
Bodycam Shows Limited On-The-Spot Protection
- Bodycam footage shows officers escorting Cardell from a support centre while her abuser continued to threaten her outside.
- Police drove her to a relative's house but did not follow up or ensure ongoing safety.