Chris Dietz, "Self-Declaration in the Legal Recognition of Gender" (Routledge, 2022)
Aug 26, 2023
auto_awesome
Chris Dietz, a lecturer at the Centre for Law & Social Justice, discusses the complexities of self-declaration in legal gender recognition. They explore Denmark's progressive gender recognition law, the challenges faced by transgender individuals, and the impact of jurisdiction on legal recognition. The podcast also touches on the discriminatory nature of healthcare access, the importance of visibility in trans rights, and the significance of political nuance in relation to human rights.
Denmark's shift to a self-declaration model for legal recognition of gender led to stricter regulations in accessing healthcare for transgender individuals.
Increased visibility of trans people in contemporary culture does not guarantee progress in trans rights, as the backlash against trans rights has been significant.
Access to healthcare is crucial for trans individuals' rights and well-being, and despite legal progress, access to healthcare for trans people has worsened.
Deep dives
TIAA's Mission: Helping Black Americans Save for Retirement
TIAA is on a mission to address the financial challenges faced by Black Americans in retirement. With 54% of Black Americans lacking sufficient savings, TIAA released Paper Right, a collection of music by artists like Wyclef Jean. All streaming sales of Paper Right go to a nonprofit organization that teaches students about investing, aiming to close the savings gap.
The Shift in Gender Recognition Laws: UK vs Denmark
Dr. Chris Dietz's book, 'Self-Diagnosis in the Legal Recognition of Gender,' explores the changes in gender recognition laws in the UK and Denmark. The UK's Gender Recognition Act of 2004 required a psychiatric diagnosis of gender dysphoria for legal recognition, but Denmark shifted to a self-declaration model in 2014. However, Denmark's progressive legal reforms were accompanied by stricter regulations in accessing healthcare, leading to challenges for transgender individuals in obtaining necessary treatments and support.
Challenges of Visibility and Progress in Trans Rights
The visibility of trans people in contemporary culture does not necessarily guarantee progress in trans rights. Despite increased visibility, the backlash against trans rights has been significant. The chapter explores the idea of embracing opacity and granting rights without demanding constant explanations from trans individuals. It also raises concerns about the concentration of power in medical institutions, which can limit access to healthcare and perpetuate vulnerabilities for trans individuals.
The Importance of Access to Healthcare
Access to healthcare is crucial for the rights and well-being of trans individuals. Despite legal progress in recognizing transgender rights, the podcast highlights that the access to healthcare for trans people has worsened. This unexpected outcome challenges the notion that legal recognition is the sole means of protecting rights. The centralized and standardized regulation of trans people has proven to be problematic, affecting their healthcare rights. This serves as a valuable lesson in understanding the power dynamics between trans individuals, the law, and the medical profession.
Examining Legal Embodiment and Jurisdictional Boundaries
The podcast delves into the concept of legal embodiment and how it relates to the power dynamics between trans individuals, law, and medicine. By focusing on the institutional aspects of embodiment, the impact of regulatory governance on trans people is examined. Additionally, the discussion explores jurisdictional boundaries between institutions such as law and medicine, emphasizing the significance of defining and balancing their roles. The analysis reveals how these boundaries shape professional discretion and the allocation of rights, ultimately shaping the experiences of trans individuals within the legal and medical systems.
Self-Declaration in the Legal Recognition of Gender(Routledge, 2023) is a socio-legal study that offers a critique of what it means to self-declare with regard to legal gender. Based on empirical research conducted in Denmark, the book engages in some of the most controversial issues surrounding trans and gender diverse rights. The theoretical analysis draws upon legal consciousness, affect theory, vulnerability and governmentality, to cross jurisdictional boundaries between law and medicine. The book reflects on the limits of progress that legislative reform may make, and the way that increased regulation can actually limit access to rights protections. Broadly transferrable beyond its specific field, this book will be useful to socio-legal scholars, feminist scholars, trans scholars, policy makers and practitioners.
Dr Chris Dietz is a Lecturer at the Centre for Law & Social Justice at The University of Leeds.
Jane Richards is a doctoral student at the University of Hong Kong. You can find her on twitter where she follows all things related to human rights and Hong Kong politics @JaneRichardsHK