Nathan Schlueter, a professor of Philosophy and Religion at Hillsdale College, dives into the stark contrasts between the American and French revolutions. He discusses how differing ideologies have shaped modern political landscapes and the critiques emerging from both sides of the political spectrum. Schlueter emphasizes the importance of statesmanship and education in upholding virtues necessary for governance, while also reflecting on the radical legacy of the French Revolution and its implications for contemporary society.
The American Revolution resulted in a stable democracy due to its grounding in moral virtues, unlike the chaotic French Revolution.
The podcast underscores the essential role of statesmanship and education in nurturing virtuous citizens to strengthen contemporary governance.
Deep dives
Contrasting Revolutions: American and French
The American and French revolutions emerged from similar liberal principles but diverged significantly in their outcomes. The American Revolution fostered a relatively stable and prosperous democracy, while the French Revolution devolved into a period of chaos and violence, exemplified by the Reign of Terror. Notably, the execution of King Louis XVI in 1793 and the establishment of the guillotine marked a stark departure from the values espoused in the American founding. This divergence highlights the importance of statesmanship and the dangers of unchecked populism prevalent during the French Revolution.
Philosophical Foundations and Moral Virtues
A critical difference between the two revolutions lies in their foundational documents and the acknowledgment of moral virtues. The Declaration of Independence articulated values rooted in divine providence and natural law, emphasizing the need for prudence in governance. In contrast, the French Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen lacked a mention of moral virtues, leading to a more abstract and aggressive interpretation of liberty and reason. This philosophical distinction fueled the negative trajectory of the French Revolution, where the absence of moral grounding resulted in the purging of tradition and religion.
Lessons for Modern Governance
The discussion emphasizes the need for statesmanship and responsible leadership in contemporary governance to avoid the pitfalls highlighted by the French Revolution. Leaders are urged to foster trust and elevate public discourse rather than engage in adversarial politics that undermine societal cohesion. Additionally, the critical role of education is underscored as a means to cultivate virtuous citizens capable of sustaining a just political order. Learning from the past allows for a deeper understanding of human nature and guides the pursuit of political stability in today's complex landscape.
Nathan Schlueter, professor of Philosophy and Religion at Hillsdale College, joins host Scot Bertram to discuss the differences between the American and French revolutions, growing intellectual movements critical of the American Revolution, and the importance of cultivating the virtue of statesmanship.
----------------------------
A 20-minute podcast featuring professors, K-12 teachers, and friends of Hillsdale College, all speaking about classical education—what it is, why it’s still relevant today, and what makes it unique. Hosted by Scot Bertram.
Learn More About The Hillsdale College Podcast Network: https://podcast.hillsdale.edu