

What Does "Creation" Really Mean? w/ Fr. Gregory Pine, O.P. & Dr. William Carroll
Dec 5, 2024
Fr. Gregory Pine, O.P. hosts Dr. William Carroll, an expert in intellectual history and the history of science. They unpack St. Thomas Aquinas’s profound insights on creation, discussing how it intertwines with time and cosmology. The conversation reveals the historical tensions between faith and science, particularly through the Galileo-Inquisition episode. They also explore the concept of 'conceptual therapy' to tackle misconceptions in cosmology and clarify the nature of creation ex nihilo, enhancing our understanding of the relationship between existence and creation.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Modernity's Narrative on Creation
- Modernity's narrative, tied to the 17th-century scientific revolution, often frames traditional views of creation as outdated.
- This narrative promotes a perceived conflict between science and religion, where science has supposedly won.
Creation as Dependence
- Creation, as Aquinas defines it, is not about the universe's beginning but a dependence in existence.
- Confusing creation with a change is a category mistake leading to misinterpretations of cosmology.
Philosophical vs. Theological Creation
- Aquinas distinguishes philosophical creation (dependence in being) from theological creation (including a beginning).
- The universe's temporality is irrelevant to its created status philosophically.