Can Prophets Make Mistakes? A Candid Conversation with Scott Woodward Part 2 | E0004
May 4, 2023
auto_awesome
In a thought-provoking conversation, Scott Woodward, who engages deeply in discussions about prophecy and church history, tackles the challenging topic of prophetic error. He explores the complex history of race and priesthood restrictions, emphasizing the importance of understanding human fallibility among prophets. The dialog delves into themes of forgiveness, accountability, and divine grace, highlighting how the Church's views on race have evolved. Woodward stresses the significance of compassion and redemption within faith communities, encouraging a reflective approach to history.
The podcast argues that prophets can make mistakes, emphasizing the importance of accepting their fallibility to better understand church history.
It examines the historical priesthood restrictions for black individuals, highlighting how cultural biases influenced doctrinal decisions and the narrative of prophetic infallibility.
Deep dives
Understanding Prophetic Fallibility
The concept of prophetic infallibility is a common myth in the context of Latter-day Saint teachings. It is argued that both prophets and apostles are inherently weak, error-prone, and sinful, as indicated in Doctrine and Covenants. This understanding is reinforced through examples like Joseph Smith's practice of plural marriage, where it is emphasized that the challenge lies in allowing for the fallibility of these leaders rather than defending their every action. Embracing this perspective offers a healthier approach to understanding church history and the human condition within it.
The Impact of Race in the Priesthood
The historical restriction of priesthood access for black individuals significantly challenges the narrative that prophets are infallible. Initially, during Joseph Smith's leadership, there were no such restrictions, as he ordained black men like Elijah Abel, who actively participated in church activities. However, under Brigham Young, these restrictions changed, leading to widely accepted yet unfounded beliefs that linked race to divine retribution. This historical shift highlights the need to view past actions critically, recognizing how cultural biases influenced doctrinal decisions within the church.
Revelation and Church Leadership
Revelation in the church hinges upon the unity of its leadership, demonstrated by the significant 1978 revelation that lifted priesthood restrictions. This pivotal moment occurred only when the First Presidency and the Quorum of the Twelve were united in their inquiry to God regarding this matter. Their collective confirmation of the revelation underscores how divine guidance can manifest in response to unified leadership efforts. This historical lesson stresses the importance of focusing on God's mercy and grace, as He works with flawed individuals to guide His church.
The Role of Jesus Christ's Atonement
The overarching theme of Jesus Christ's atonement plays a crucial role in reconciling historical grievances stemming from prophetic actions. This atonement is viewed as a powerful redemptive force that encompasses not only individual sins but also collective mistakes made throughout church history. The belief that God can redeem even the most significant historical errors fosters hope and understanding in those grappling with difficult issues in church teachings. Emphasizing personal and communal forgiveness allows believers to find peace in their spiritual journeys while recognizing the complexities of their faith.
This episode discusses the sensitive topic of prophetic error and the Church’s black African priesthood & temple restriction that was in place more or less for over 100 years. As the history is discussed, it may be helpful for viewers to remember the following crucial statement made in the Church’s 2013 Race & Priesthood essay: “Today, the Church disavows the theories advanced in the past that black skin is a sign of divine disfavor or curse, or that it reflects unrighteous actions in a premortal life; that mixed-race marriages are a sin; or that blacks or people of any other race or ethnicity are inferior in any way to anyone else. Church leaders today unequivocally condemn all racism, past and present, in any form."