Best of the Spectator Holy Smoke: Pope Francis dies – what will his legacy be?
Apr 21, 2025
Father Alexander Lucie-Smith, a Catholic priest and moral theologian, joins Damian Thompson to discuss the transformative legacy of Pope Francis following his death. They delve into Francis's complex embrace of social issues that polarized both liberals and conservatives. The conversation highlights how his Argentinian roots and connections to Peronism influenced his papacy. Lucie-Smith also reflects on the historical shift in the Church's governance and the challenges faced in precisely defining Francis’s legacy amidst his controversial decisions.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Francis’ Complex Papacy
- Pope Francis was one of the most memorable and controversial popes in centuries.
- His combination of empathy, austerity, and deliberate conflict stirring defined his leadership.
Beyond Left and Right
- Francis defies easy political categorization, not fitting left or right-wing labels.
- His deep devotion to the Virgin Mary highlights spiritual dimensions often overlooked.
Mixed Signals to Conservatives and Liberals
- Francis antagonized traditionalist conservatives while placating some left-wing groups rhetorically.
- Despite liberal hopes, his actual doctrinal changes were limited, disappointing leftists.