Scratch & Win Why do some parts of government work better than others?
19 snips
Apr 2, 2025 
Marc Dunkelman, a research fellow at Brown University and author of "Why Nothing Works," dives into why some government projects are met with scrutiny while others succeed quietly. He contrasts the controversial Big Dig with the successful state lottery, exploring the dynamics of government efficiency and effectiveness. The discussion touches on historical governance tensions, the evolution of welfare programs, and the crucial balance between public involvement and efficient bureaucracy. Dunkelman’s insights invite listeners to reconsider the factors shaping government outcomes.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Two Impulses of Progressivism
- American progressivism has two core impulses: Hamiltonian and Jeffersonian.
- These impulses represent centralizing vs. decentralizing power, often conflicting within individuals.
TVA and Robert Moses
- The Tennessee Valley Authority exemplifies Hamiltonian progressivism, granting centralized power for rural electrification.
- Robert Moses, initially praised, later criticized, illustrates how public perception of these projects shifts.
Influence of "The Power Broker"
- Robert Caro's "The Power Broker" significantly influenced public opinion against centralized planning.
- It fueled a Jeffersonian narrative, emphasizing individual freedom from powerful authorities.
