Matthew McManus, "The Political Right and Equality: Turning Back the Tide of Egalitarian Modernity" (Routledge, 2023)
Sep 13, 2023
auto_awesome
Matthew McManus, an intellectual historian of the conservative and reactionary tradition, presents an intellectual history of the political right, tracing its core to a nostalgia for hierarchical cosmos. He argues for a better understanding of the right's critiques towards equality and freedom. McManus suggests that hostility to equality unites the right and explores perspectives on what it means to be on the political right, the fusion of capitalism and social conservatism in the American right, the distinction between the political right and the far right, and the origins and development of liberal socialism.
The political right's admiration for orderly political and social stratification stems from a nostalgia for an hierarchical societal structure.
The contemporary rise of right-wing forces can be attributed to a shared hostility towards the quest for equality and freedom.
Deep dives
Whole Foods Market Savings
During the Kickstart the Season event at Whole Foods Market, customers can take advantage of a huge sale on supplements, such as vitamins, protein powders, and probiotics. Additionally, there are wallet-friendly prices on breakfast items like organic eggs and bacon. Families can also enjoy the convenience of bringing home a pre-prepared family meal from Whole Foods Market. Terms apply.
Stigma and HIV Testing
A survey revealed that 27% of individuals with HIV delayed getting tested due to the stigma surrounding the virus. It is crucial to address this stigma and increase awareness about HIV to support those who are living with the condition. More information and resources can be found at StopHIVIowa.org.
The Notion of Superiority in Right-Wing Thinking
In exploring the origins of right-wing thinking, it is argued that a core belief of the political right is the notion of recognizably superior individuals in society. Different conservative authors have their own interpretations of who these superior people are, but this conviction forms the basis of right-wing ideology. This belief can be traced back to antiquity, with figures like Aristotle endorsing hierarchical social structures. However, the concept of superiority has evolved, and various right-wing thinkers, including Hegel and Dostoevsky, have contributed to its development.
McManus presents an intellectual history of the conservative and reactionary tradition, stretching from Aristotle and Filmer to Alexander Dugin and Patrick Deneen.
Providing a comprehensive critical genealogy of the intellectual political right, McManus traces its core to a nostalgia for the hierarchical cosmos of antiquarian and scholastic thinking. The yearning for a shared vision of the universe where each part of reality has its place maps onto the conservative admiration for orderly political and social stratification. It stamps even the more moderate forms of liberal conservatism which emerged in the aftermath of the revolutionary 18th century, as the political right struggled to accept and later master first the politics of liberal capitalism and later universal suffrage. In its most radical forms this nostalgia for an orderly and hierarchical existence can harden into a resentment at the perceived shallowness of liberal modernity. McManus argues for those who support the project of modernity to commit themselves to better understanding the depth of the political right’s critiques, many of which expose uncomfortable but solvable problems with the quest for equality and freedom.
While there are a lot of competing explanations for the contemporary rise of right-wing forces, Matt McManus’ new book suggests that it is hostility to equality that actually unites the right. Zeroing in on key intellectuals and writers, McManus, in a sharply written text, offers a compelling explanation for the disproportionate intensity of right-wing grievance politics
Matthew McManus is a Lecturer in Political Science at the University of Michigan. He is a contributor to Jacobin and Quillette online magazines.
Morteza Hajizadeh is a Ph.D. graduate in English from the University of Auckland in New Zealand. His research interests are Cultural Studies; Critical Theory; Environmental History; Medieval (Intellectual) History; Gothic Studies; 18th and 19th Century British Literature. YouTube channel.