Explore the Stoic idea of 'indifferents' and the three value categories. Delve into defining good and indifferents. Understand how to live with indifferents and prioritize virtue over vice. Learn about the importance of indifference in Stoicism for making virtuous decisions and finding true happiness.
Indifference in Stoicism encompasses most aspects of life neither inherently good nor bad, guiding daily decisions.
Stoics define good and bad as limited in number, always beneficial or harmful, contrasting with the nuanced indifference considerations.
Stoic indifference ranges from preferred to unpreferred elements, with choices influenced by contextual factors and individual preferences.
Deep dives
Understanding Indifference in Stoicism
Indifference plays a crucial role in Stoicism, serving as a central concept alongside virtue and happiness. While good and bad are few in number and always motivating, indifference encompass most things in life that are neither inherently good nor bad. These include health, pleasure, reputation, wealth, and social relationships, forming the bulk of daily decision-making. Preferable indifference can be pursued unless a valid reason dictates otherwise, showcasing the importance of navigating them wisely.
Defining Good and Bad in Stoicism
In Stoicism, good and bad are defined by their necessary value and motivating nature. Good things must always benefit and inherently motivate pursuit, while bad things inflict harm and prompt avoidance. Stoics emphasize the scarce number of good and bad elements, depicting them as equally valuable without varying degrees. The strict binary nature of good and bad contrasts with the nuanced considerations of indifference.
Navigating Indifference and Preference
Indifference in Stoicism consist of a broad range of elements that can be classified as preferred or not. While some indifference align with natural inclinations and are typically preferred, the choice to pursue them depends on contextual factors. Stoic philosophy acknowledges the subjective preferences individuals hold towards certain indifference, emphasizing the importance of making appropriate selections based on virtue and reason.
Demonstrating Virtue Through Indifference
Indifference in Stoicism serve as the materials through which individuals showcase their good character and practical wisdom. While good and bad set the moral framework, the virtuous display their excellence by engaging with indifference in a virtuous manner. These everyday decisions involving indifference reflect the individual's commitment to applying Stoic principles in their daily lives, illustrating the nuanced interplay between character development and choices.
Balancing Preferences with Stoic Virtue
Stoicism permits individuals to hold preferences for certain indifference while maintaining an understanding of their ultimate neutrality in determining happiness. The philosophy emphasizes acting virtuously through interactions with indifference, showcasing prudence and excellence in decision-making. The Stoic approach involves acknowledging the value of these preferences while prioritizing the demonstration of virtue through the thoughtful navigation of indifference.
In this episode, Michael presents the Stoic idea of "indifferents." It’s one of the key ideas behind Stoicism, one’s that often misunderstood but necessary to know in order to understand Stoicism.
(02:52) The 3 Value Categories
(06:22) Defining Good
(15:32) Defining Indifferents
(37:32) Total Indifferents
(39:06) How To Live With Indifferents
(51:22) Summary
***
Subscribe to The Stoa Letter for weekly meditations, actions, and links to the best Stoic resources: www.stoaletter.com/subscribe