John McTernan, a veteran political advisor with experience working for prime ministers in both the UK and Australia, shares his insights into the tumultuous role of a political advisor. He discusses the highs and lows of guiding leaders, emphasizing the blend of strategy and chaos. The conversation dives into the complexities of modern conservatism, analyzing Kemi Badenoch's unique approach and the challenges facing political parties amidst cultural shifts. McTernan also reveals the intricacies of navigating political rivalries and maintaining authenticity in communications.
Political advisors play a crucial role in shaping strategies and policies, requiring a deep understanding of their leaders' ideologies and managing competing interests.
Kemi Badenoch's recent speech illustrates her vision for conservatism, emphasizing Western values but indicating a need for clearer economic policies to resonate with voters.
Deep dives
The Impact of Technocracy on Politics
The podcast discusses the ongoing influence of technocracy in political leadership, emphasizing the roles of key figures like Polly McKenzie and Danny Finkelstein. They highlight how technocrats often drive political narratives while being at the forefront of discussions, such as those concerning voter concerns and governmental policies. The guests express mixed feelings about previous episodes, noting that while diverse perspectives are valued, there is also a segment of the audience that feels overwhelmed by repeated topics. This indicates a continuous tension in engaging various political ideologies while maintaining listener interest.
Kemi Badenoch's Conservative Vision
Kemi Badenoch's recent speech at the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship is analyzed, where she articulates a vision for conservatism emphasizing Western values and the need for a new conservative century. The discussion reveals that her approach includes a defense of free markets and the rule of law, though some argue she falls short in addressing pressing economic issues. The guests contemplate her ability to resonate with constituents who are largely unfamiliar with her, noting a general curiosity about her perspectives. There is a consensus that while she is an engaging figure, further articulation of her economic policies is necessary for a comprehensive conservative agenda.
The Role of Ideology in Elections
The podcast delves into whether political ideologies and values are crucial for winning elections or merely serve as placeholders when candidates struggle to define their goals. The conversation suggests that a party's foundational view is vital for its identity and strategy, as exemplified by historical references to leaders like Margaret Thatcher. The participants discuss how capturing a coalition of diverse ideologies can be complex, especially when addressing opposing factions within a party. A key takeaway is the necessity for politicians to clearly establish their values to resonate with voters and define their leadership effectively.
Political Advisors and Their Influence
A significant portion of the podcast is dedicated to the impact of political advisors in shaping policies and strategies within governments. The guests, who have extensive advising experience, characterize the role as a form of public service that allows individuals to contribute to the political landscape while grappling with the pressures of the job. They outline the importance of navigating internal conflicts and securing collective buy-in over ambitious yet practicable strategies. Furthermore, the discussion reveals that the effectiveness of advisors often hinges on their ability to understand and engage with their leaders' ideologies while managing competing interests.
What's the role of an adviser at the top level of politics, and does it always involve swearing?
John McTernan, who has worked for prime ministers in the UK and Australia, joins the political masterminds to discuss the highs and the lows of the job. And after Kemi Badenoch speaks at a gathering of right-of-centre thinkers in London, what have we learned about her brand of Conservatism?
Send questions, comments and voicenotes to: howtowin@thetimes.co.uk