The McShay Show Rivalry Week Tape Truths: Bama’s D, A&M’s Title Shot, ACC Playoff Hopes, and More
Dec 2, 2025
The guys dive into the fallout from Rivalry Week in college football, spotlighting Texas A&M's potential playoff run despite some inconsistencies. They argue Alabama's defense is seriously underrated and discuss its elite playmakers. Todd shines a light on Ty Simpson's clutch performances, even when the stats don’t reflect it. The success of Texas Tech's GM is also highlighted as a significant story, while Caden McDonald’s impact on Ohio State's defense is praised. Finally, the ACC's playoff hopes hinge on Virginia's standout performances.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Why Texas A&M Can Still Run
- Texas A&M is capable of beating anyone on a given day and can make a CFP run despite inconsistencies.
- Marcel Reed's play is erratic but the Aggies have talent, depth, and can catch fire for a four-game stretch.
Value Of A Timely Loss
- A late-season loss can recalibrate a team and serve as a key coaching tool to fix shortcomings.
- Todd McShay thinks A&M's Texas loss might refocus the roster ahead of a playoff push.
Alabama's Underrated Defensive Rise
- Alabama's defense has improved steadily and is among the nation's best, led by a versatile secondary and deep linebacker group.
- Bray Hubbard and the linebackers provide playmaking and rotational depth that elevate the unit weekly.