Could This Vitalik-Backed Protocol Bring Privacy to a Regulated Crypto World? - Ep. 542
Sep 8, 2023
auto_awesome
Vitalik Buterin and co-authors published a paper on a protocol called privacy pools to address the shortcomings of coin mixer Tornado Cash. Chainalysis chief scientist Jacob Illum discusses the motivation behind the paper, how privacy pools work using zero-knowledge proofs, and the role of association set providers. They also explore scenarios, privacy protection, and the involvement of law enforcement and credit score agencies.
Privacy pools, a smart contract protocol, can help differentiate legitimate funds from those used in criminal activities on the blockchain.
Association set providers play a crucial role in privacy pools, allowing users to selectively associate their funds with specific sets.
Deep dives
Importance of Privacy for Blockchain Adoption
The podcast episode discusses the importance of privacy in blockchain adoption. The speaker believes that everyone should have the right to use blockchain in their desired way. The speaker argues that providing privacy options, such as association sets with withdrawals, can lead to greater adoption of blockchain. The recent incidents involving privacy tools like Tornado Cash and government sanctions have highlighted the need for technological solutions. The proposed solution is the concept of privacy pools, where users can selectively choose to associate or dissociate their funds with specific sets. This offers users the flexibility to disassociate from potentially controversial activities while still utilizing blockchain technology.
Privacy Pools: Technical Solution for Financial Privacy
The podcast episode introduces the concept of privacy pools as a technical solution for financial privacy on the blockchain. The privacy pools are built on zero-knowledge proofs, which allow users to prove the association or disassociation of their funds without revealing specific details. The technology enables users to participate in a pool of funds selectively and validate the withdrawal based on their chosen set of associations. The proposed solution provides privacy while maintaining transparency and integrity on the blockchain. It also addresses the issue of funds being mistakenly associated with illicit activities and offers a way for users to dissociate from such transactions.
Role of Association Set Providers in Privacy Pools
The podcast episode discusses the role of association set providers in privacy pools. Association set providers are intermediaries who assign properties to the deposits flowing into the pool. These providers analyze the blockchain and determine which deposits are from legitimate sources. Users can then choose to associate their funds with specific sets provided by these intermediaries. This allows users without blockchain analytics expertise to make informed decisions about their association with certain deposits. The proposed system relies on trust in association set providers, which can be organizations, companies, or entities knowledgeable about the regulatory and jurisdictional aspects of blockchain transactions.
Considerations and Reactions to Privacy Pools
The podcast episode discusses various considerations and reactions to privacy pools. It acknowledges some criticism, such as concerns about the technology resembling permissioned chains or compromising privacy. However, the speaker emphasizes the importance of maintaining the strengths of blockchain, including transparency and integrity. The speaker highlights that privacy pools offer a way to balance privacy needs with wider adoption of blockchain. The technology's proposal has received reactions in the crypto community, sparking discussions on the technology's implementation, potential associations set providers, and the need for further development in achieving privacy on the blockchain.
Earlier this week, Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin and four co-authors published a paper describing a smart contract protocol called privacy pools that would enable crypto users to associate their funds with those being used for legitimate purposes versus those being used in criminal activity such as hacks or money laundering. The protocol addresses one of the main shortcomings of coin mixer Tornado Cash, which has been sanctioned by the U.S. government.
Chainalysis chief scientist Jacob Illum, one of those co-authors, discusses the impetus for the paper, the technology behind privacy pools and how they would work in practice, who would provide some of the necessary organization to operate the pools, and some of the early criticisms of the paper.