The Commentary Magazine Podcast

Just and Unjust Blabbermouths

Sep 23, 2024
The podcast critiques arguments about the legality of attacks in warfare and the reliability of polling data. It discusses the messy intersection of health crises and military conflicts, questioning the traditional just war theory. Social media's role in shaping political outrage is analyzed, with historical parallels drawn. Diplomatic challenges involving Hamas and U.S. responses receive a satirical spin. Finally, it navigates polling politics, emphasizing the complex dynamics within the Jewish community in the context of presidential races.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Israel's Measured Response

  • Israel's response to Hezbollah's attacks has been measured, focusing on electronic device targeting.
  • This strategy aims to pressure Lebanon's government to control Hezbollah or face broader conflict.
ANECDOTE

Health Ministry Reports

  • The Lebanese Health Ministry is now reporting casualties without distinguishing between Hezbollah and civilians.
  • This follows a similar pattern seen with the Gaza Health Ministry, raising concerns about accurate reporting.
INSIGHT

Just War Debate

  • Michael Walzer criticizes Israel's electronic device attacks for violating just war principles by targeting non-combatants.
  • The podcasters argue that Hezbollah terrorists, who don't wear uniforms and live among civilians, blur the lines of traditional warfare.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app