The podcast discusses how NATO accession could strengthen Ukraine's position against Russia, drawing parallels to West Germany's history. The importance of setting clear red lines for Moscow and European efforts to ensure lasting peace in the region are highlighted. The episode explores perspectives on negotiations with Russia and the potential de-escalation impact of Ukraine's NATO membership.
Russian could exploit West's electoral uncertainty for a settlement deal.
NATO accession can bolster Ukraine's negotiation power and reinforce West's red lines.
Deep dives
The Different Wars in Ukraine
The podcast discusses the complexity of the wars in Ukraine, explaining that the conflict did not start in 2022 but dates back to 2014. It highlights Russia's involvement in attempting to politically control Ukraine, leading to different phases of war. The current war is seen as a clash of civilizations between Russia and the West, emphasizing the evolving nature of conflict and the need to redefine victory and defeat.
Importance of Implementing the West German Model
The podcast delves into the 'West German scenario' for Ukraine, drawing parallels to Germany's post-war division and later integration. It emphasizes the significance of Ukraine retaining its Western orientation and warns against compromises on its territorial integrity. Implementing the West German model is proposed as a strategy to prevent Ukraine from becoming a depopulated, demilitarized state that threatens European stability.
NATO Membership for Ukraine and Western Unity
The need for Ukraine to enter NATO as a means of strengthening its position in negotiations and ensuring security guarantees is discussed. The podcast highlights Western reticence and the potential impact of a divided approach on NATO's credibility. Emphasizing the importance of collective defense, it suggests signaling resolve to Russia while navigating internal debates on NATO enlargement and maintaining Western unity in confronting Russian aggression.
The conflict in Ukraine has crystallised into a war of attrition. As military losses pile up on both sides, Russia could take advantage of this year’s electoral uncertainty in the West to strike a settlement deal on its terms. To ensure a durable peace, Europeans must make clear what red lines Moscow is not allowed to cross. And the history of the cold war may provide Europeans with some valuable lessons on how to do that.
In this episode, Mark Leonard welcomes ECFR’s board member Ivan Krastev, who is the chairman of the Centre for Liberal Strategies in Sofia and a permanent fellow at Vienna’s Institute for Human Sciences. Together they discuss how NATO accession could strengthen Kyiv’s negotiating position vis-à-vis Russia and if it could enforce the West’s red lines in Ukraine in the same way as it did in West Germany almost 70 years ago. How should the West approach negotiations with Moscow? What is the de-escalation potential of Ukraine’s NATO membership? How can Europeans ensure a durable peace on the continent?