Jon Finer, distinguished visiting fellow at Columbia University's Center on Global Energy Policy, discusses the critical intersection of energy, climate change, and national security. He highlights how the Biden administration addressed challenges like Russia's energy tactics post-Ukraine invasion and climate negotiations. Finer also delves into the complexities of financing the energy transition, the implications of U.S. oil independence, and how AI intersects with national security amidst rising global competition, especially with China.
Climate change is increasingly viewed as a core national security issue, linking resource scarcity to potential conflicts and humanitarian crises.
The evolution of U.S. energy policy now encompasses a broader spectrum, addressing resource competition and clean energy initiatives alongside traditional oil concerns.
Balancing immediate energy security needs with ambitious climate goals is essential, as evidenced by the U.S. response to Russia's invasion of Ukraine.
Deep dives
Climate Change as a National Security Threat
The increasing impact of climate change is framed as a significant driver of global instability, affecting national security considerations. The changing climate leads to extreme weather events and resource scarcity, which can precipitate conflicts and migration, creating humanitarian crises. The U.S. military has recognized climate change as a core national security issue for over a decade, integrating it into strategic national defense planning. By understanding these links, policymakers can better address the multifaceted challenges posed by a changing climate and its repercussions on global stability.
Energy and Foreign Policy Intersections
Energy policy has evolved from a primary focus on oil prices and Middle Eastern relations to encompass a broader array of resources, including critical minerals and clean energy competition, particularly with China. The Biden administration navigated complex energy dynamics during its tenure, notably in response to Russia's aggressive energy policies and climate talks against challenging diplomatic backdrops. This shift represents a significant change in how national security discussions incorporate energy as a central theme, highlighting its growing importance in international relations. Understanding these intersections is crucial for shaping effective foreign policies that address energy security in a warming world.
Balancing Climate Goals with Energy Security
The Biden administration faced the challenge of balancing ambitious climate goals with the immediate need for energy security in international relations. For instance, the response to Russia's invasion of Ukraine necessitated finding alternative energy sources for affected European nations, demonstrating the complexity of energy dependencies in global crises. This balancing act involved promoting clean energy while still using hydrocarbons to meet urgent energy demands, reflecting the multifaceted nature of energy strategies. Policymakers must navigate such tensions, ensuring that climate initiatives do not compromise immediate energy security needs.
The Role of Sanctions in Energy Politics
Sanctions play a crucial role in shaping energy politics, influencing how nations engage with each other economically and politically. The administration explored innovative approaches to sanctions, particularly targeting energy revenues from adversaries like Russia and Iran while mitigating impacts on global oil markets. This strategy highlighted the need for a careful balance in applying sanctions that target specific entities without causing widespread disruptiveness to global economies. Understanding the nuances of energy sanctions is essential for formulating effective foreign policy that addresses both geopolitical goals and economic realities.
Competition with China in the Energy Transition
U.S. competition with China in the realm of clean energy is characterized by a strategic interplay of energy policy and national security concerns. The increasing Chinese dominance in manufacturing clean energy technologies contrasts sharply with their simultaneous expansion of coal-fired power plants, complicating collaborative efforts on emissions reductions. The Biden administration aimed to leverage U.S. innovation and investments to compete with China, emphasizing the importance of developing and diversifying supply chains for critical minerals and technology. As energy and climate together shape the future of national security, effective policies must navigate these competitive dynamics while promoting orderly transitions to sustainable energy.
Energy and climate change are becoming ever more central to America's national security. It used to be that foreign policy and national security discussions related to energy focused primarily on oil prices and Middle East relations. Now, these conversations also include topics like critical mineral supply chains, clean energy competition with China, climate instability, and more.
The Biden administration navigated this increasingly complex terrain for four years. It confronted Russia's weaponization of energy following its invasion of Ukraine; managed climate negotiations with difficult diplomatic relationships; and reshaped America's approach to energy security in a warming world.
So how should we think about the intersection of energy, climate, and national security going forward? And what lessons can we draw from the Biden administration's experience?
This week host Jason Bordoff talks with Jon Finer about the intersection of energy, climate change, and national security.
Jon is a distinguished visiting fellow at the Center on Global Energy Policy at Columbia University SIPA. He recently served as deputy national security advisor in the Biden administration, where he was a key architect of the administration's foreign policy. Prior to that role, Jon served in the Obama administration for seven and a half years in various positions, including chief of staff to Secretary of State John Kerry. Jon began his career in journalism, first covering Major League Baseball before moving to the security beat, covering conflicts in Iraq and other regions for the Washington Post.
Credits: Hosted by Jason Bordoff and Bill Loveless. Produced by Erin Hardick, Mary Catherine O’Connor, Caroline Pitman, and Kyu Lee. Additional support from Caroline Pitman, Jon Elkind, Kevin Brennan, Luisa Palacios and Kyu Lee. Engineering by Sean Marquand. Stephen Lacey is executive producer.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
