Dan McClellan - Does the Bible Say Jesus is God? (N344)
May 9, 2025
auto_awesome
Dan McClellan, a Bible scholar and social media influencer, delves into the complex question of Jesus's divinity. He examines early Christian texts and suggests varied interpretations that challenge traditional beliefs. The discussion highlights how evolving theology and political contexts shaped ideas about Jesus. The hosts, Tim Nash and Anna Robinson, share personal reflections on their journey with questions of faith and the nature of God, emphasizing the importance of intellectual honesty and spiritual openness in these profound inquiries.
The podcast explores diverse interpretations of Jesus's identity in the New Testament, questioning whether he is divine in a Trinitarian sense.
It emphasizes that biblical texts are interpreted through individual and cultural lenses, leading to varying understandings of scripture's meaning.
The discussion highlights the impact of early church politics on theological conclusions, particularly in solidifying the Dogma of the Trinity against alternative views.
Listeners are encouraged to question their faith journey as a way to foster deeper understanding, compassion, and authenticity in spiritual practice.
Deep dives
Exploring the Complexity of Jesus
The podcast delves into the various interpretations of Jesus's identity, highlighting the diversity found in the New Testament writings. It discusses how different Gospel authors present distinct views about Jesus, questioning whether he was considered divine in a Trinitarian sense or as a human divine agent. Mark and John, for instance, portray varying aspects of Jesus's nature, from potentially adopting a divine role at baptism to emanating from God as the Logos. This multifaceted nature of Jesus’s portrayal serves to connect with listeners on a deeper level, suggesting that the understanding of Jesus is not fixed but rather an evolving narrative shaped by cultural and historical contexts.
The Role of the Bible in Negotiating Meaning
In discussing the Bible, the podcast underscores the idea that it does not dictate meaning but is instead interpreted through the lens of individual and cultural perspectives. This negotiation results in varying interpretations and can lead to a malleable understanding of scripture, which allows it to be used in a range of contexts. The hosts point out that different dogmas, such as inerrancy and authority, often serve to enforce certain readings over others, particularly those that prioritize the interests of dominant groups. This dynamic raises questions about how these interpretations affect marginalized communities, emphasizing the need for critical engagement with scriptural texts.
Jesus as a Human Role Model
The podcast contemplates the implications of viewing Jesus as primarily human rather than divine, arguing that his actions and teachings can serve as relatable models for human behavior. This perspective encourages a more human-centric understanding of spirituality and ethics, where Jesus's life exemplifies compassion and inclusivity. By reframing Jesus's divinity in this way, listeners can feel empowered to follow in his footsteps in tangible and meaningful ways. This understanding can alleviate the pressure of adhering to a strict dogma, opening the door to exploring various dimensions of faith.
The Impact of Empire on Theological Development
One key aspect discussed is how the early church's theological conclusions were heavily influenced by the political power structures of their time. The Dogma of the Trinity became solidified partly due to the influence of the Roman Empire, which sought to unify diverse interpretations into a singularly accepted form. This standardization often resulted in the marginalization of alternative views and interpretations of Jesus's identity, underlining the connection between theology and the politics of power. Consequently, understanding the historical context of these beliefs encourages modern listeners to reflect upon how power relations can shape religious narratives.
The Authority of Scripture and Its Implications
The authority traditionally ascribed to scripture is interrogated, prompting listeners to question what makes certain interpretations more valid than others. The podcast reflects on the notion that this authority is often wielded to marginalize certain groups while lifting others, creating tensions within the faith community. By discussing implications for marginalized groups, the hosts emphasize the responsibility of believers to interpret their faith in ways that align with values of love and justice. This reframing invites listeners to reconsider their own beliefs and the potential harm they may unintentionally perpetuate through unexamined dogma.
Living a Life of Love Beyond Dogma
The overarching theme of living a life imbued with love, beyond rigorous adherence to dogmatic interpretations, resonates throughout the discussions. The podcast encourages a shift away from defining faith by rigid dogmas towards a framework that emphasizes compassion and personal authenticity. Listeners are reminded that genuine faith can exist within the complexities of human experience, including uncertainties and evolving beliefs. This life-affirming approach serves to reaffirm that the essence of spiritual practice is not a matter of intellectual correctness but rather an extension of love and community.
Growing Through Questions and Doubts
Finally, the podcast highlights the importance of questioning and reflecting on one's faith journey, portraying it not as a deficit but as an integral part of spiritual growth. The hosts express how grappling with difficult theological concepts can lead to deeper understanding and connection to one’s beliefs. Rather than shy away from complexities, they suggest embracing them as opportunities for learning and exploration. This perspective encourages listeners to approach their faith as a living, breathing entity that requires ongoing curiosity and openness to transformation.
In this episode we speak with Bible scholar Dan McClellan about one of Christianity’s most foundational claims: the divinity of Jesus.
Drawing from his deep engagement with biblical scholarship, Dan invites us to consider whether the Bible actually presents Jesus as God in the way later doctrine insists. He explores how early Christian texts reflect diverse and competing understandings of Jesus’s nature, and how ideas about divinity were shaped as much by evolving theology and politics as by the biblical text itself.
Following the interview, Nomad hosts Tim Nash and Anna Robinson reflect on their own relationship with Jesus’s divinity, and what it means to engage these questions with both intellectual honesty and spiritual openness.
Interview starts at 15m 22s
If you’d like to sponsor Tim on his 165 Mito Miles in May challenge, go to his GoFundMe page.
The creation of Nomad’s thoughtful, ad-free content is entirely funded by our equally thoughtful and wonderful listeners. By supporting us, you gain access to Nomad’s online spaces—like the Beloved Listener Lounge, Enneagram Lounge, and Book Club—as well as bonus episodes such as Nomad Contemplations, Therapeutic Reflections, and Nomad Revisited.
If you’d like to join our lovely community of supporters, head over to our Patreon page. You might even be rewarded with a Nomad pen or our coveted Beloved Listener mug!
If a monthly commitment isn’t possible right now, a one-off donation is always deeply appreciated—you can do that here.
And if you're up for sharing your own story, we regularly post reflections from listeners on our blog—all with the hope of fostering deeper understanding, connection and supportive relationships. If you'd like to share your story on the blog, contact us for more information here.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
