Dr. David Gwynn, a Reader in ancient and late antique history, joins Tristan Hughes to dissect the Crisis of the Third Century in the Roman Empire. They explore the eerie frequency of emperor murders, highlighting figures like Maximinus Thrax. The conversation dives into civil wars, economic collapse, and the external threats from the Sassanians and Goths. A pivotal moment discussed is Emperor Valerian's capture, illustrating the era's chaos. Christianity's rise amidst plagues and hardships reveals a significant shift in societal values during this tumultuous time.
The Crisis of the Third Century was marked by extreme political instability, exemplified by over 25 emperors being swiftly murdered or overthrown.
External threats from the Sasanian Empire and Germanic tribes significantly stressed Rome's military capabilities and internal governance structures.
The rise of Christianity during this tumultuous period showcased its adaptability, gaining acceptance as traditional Roman religious practices waned.
Deep dives
The Complexity of the Third Century Crisis
The Third Century Crisis, spanning from 235 to 284 AD, marks one of the most transformative and chaotic periods in Roman history. More than 25 emperors rose and fell during this time, often meeting violent ends, amid widespread plague, economic collapse, and military conflicts from both external enemies and internal power struggles. The crisis emerged from a convergence of factors, including profound societal upheaval and the rise of assertive military leaders known as barracks emperors, who lacked the traditional noble lineage or administrative skills to govern effectively. Despite these hardships, the Roman Empire managed to survive, ultimately emerging from the crisis in a radically altered state.
The Role of External and Internal Threats
The Third Century Crisis was characterized by simultaneous threats across the Roman Empire's frontiers, namely the Eastern conflict with the rising Sasanian Empire and incursions from various Germanic tribes, including the Goths and Franks. The Sassanians reclaimed territories previously held by the Parthians, assertively expanding their own empire and launching attacks that severely stressed the Eastern provinces of the Roman Empire. Meanwhile, in the West, new tribal coalitions, such as the Franks and Alamanni, exploited the weakened Roman defenses, adding to the growing internal chaos caused by rapid changes in leadership. The combination of civil war and pressing external invaders created a landscape where Rome's military and administrative systems became increasingly strained.
Economic Collapse and Debasement of Currency
The economic fallout during the Third Century Crisis was marked by rampant inflation and the devaluation of currency, stemming from the need for emperors to mint more coins to fund military efforts. The silver content of Roman coins plummeted from about 40% to less than 5% by the end of the crisis, leading to a loss of trust in the currency among merchants and money lenders. This economic instability forced many regions to revert to barter systems, undermining large-scale trade routes that had previously thrived. Alongside the effects of plague and civil strife, the economic collapse weakened the overall structure of Roman governance and its ability to fund and maintain warfare.
Religious Shifts Amid the Turmoil
Amidst the chaos of the Third Century Crisis, Christianity began to gain a foothold within the Roman Empire, transitioning from a small minority to a more recognized presence. This period saw the first major persecutions of Christians under emperors like Decius and Valerian, who viewed the crises as divine punishment for rejecting traditional Roman gods. However, the Christians' organized care for the sick during plagues also contributed to their growing influence and acceptance within society. As traditional pagan practices faltered amidst unrest, Christianity's rise intertwined significantly with the broader narrative of change and survival during this tumultuous period.
Pathway to Recovery and the Formation of the Tetrarchy
The chaotic Third Century Crisis eventually set the stage for a significant recovery led by emperors like Aurelian and Diocletian, who restructured the empire to restore stability. Aurelian was instrumental in reuniting the empire, eradicating breakaway regions, and defeating external threats, while Diocletian introduced the Tetrarchy, a system that divided governance between multiple emperors to ensure better regional control and defense. This innovative approach allowed for a more localized response to threats and administrative challenges, strengthening the empire's cohesion. The organizational reforms and centralization initiated by these emperors not only addressed short-term crises but also laid important groundwork for the empire's endurance through subsequent centuries.
What happens when emperors are murdered more often than they die of natural causes? Tristan Hughes is joined by Dr. David Gwynn to unravel the Crisis of the Third Century, a pivotal, turbulent era in Roman history that served as a turning point between the classical and early medieval worlds. It was a time where soldiers like Maximinus Thrax rose to power, only to face rapid turnover and murder.
Tristan and David discuss the complex web of civil wars, external threats from formidable foes like the Sassanians, Franks, and Goths, and the ultimate capture and grotesque end of Emperor Valerian. This is the time of ancient Rome's economic collapse, devastating plagues, and the dramatic rise of Christianity.
Presented by Tristan Hughes. The audio editor and producer is Joseph Knight. The senior producer is Anne-Marie Luff.
Theme music from Motion Array, all other music from Epidemic Sounds
The Ancients is a History Hit podcast.
Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe.