Interview with Kevin Mitchell on Agency and Evolution
Mar 6, 2024
auto_awesome
In this podcast, Kevin Mitchell discusses free will, determinism, consciousness, and agency from a scientific perspective. The conversation dives into evolutionary perspectives on behavior, consciousness, quantum uncertainty, decision-making processes, meaningful information in neural processes, emotions' influence on decision-making, AI creativity, theories of human intelligence evolution, and more.
The emergence of agency in living organisms stems from indeterminacy in physical laws, allowing for control and goal achievement.
Biological and cognitive systems thrive on indeterminacy, providing the foundation for agency and control in organisms.
Selfhood is viewed as a continuity of patterns over time, rejecting the notion of a separate, isolated self as an entity.
Experiments highlighting unconscious processes don't negate the complexity of agency and self-awareness in decision-making.
Language plays a pivotal role in shaping thought and enabling abstract thinking for problem-solving and creative processes.
Deep dives
The Concept of Agency and Emergence of Life
Life is characterized by agency, where living organisms act and interact with their environment. The emergence of agency is tied to the existence of causal slack or indeterminacy in the universe, allowing for macroscopic organization to evolve. This agency is crucial for organisms to control their actions and achieve their goals, based on functional systems that embody control policies.
Determinism and Free Will Debate
The deterministic view of the universe questions the possibility of free will, but the debate rests on assumptions that overlook the evidence of indeterminacy in physical laws. Indeterminacy creates room for emergence of biological and cognitive systems, providing the basis for agency and control in living organisms. The ability to control actions is not about prefiguring every atom, but about achieving desired goals within certain limits.
Understanding the Nature of the Self
The concept of the self is often debated, ranging from dualistic views to nihilistic perspectives. Rejecting the idea of a separate, isolatable self as an entity, it is argued that the self is a continuity of patterns over time, manifesting as a bundle of memories, attitudes, and dispositions. This conception still allows for selfhood and agency without the need for a localized, distinct object.
Critique of Experiments on Consciousness and Self Attribution
Experiments like the Libet experiment and split brain research highlighting unconscious mental processes raise questions about conscious authorship and post hoc narratives. However, these experiments do not negate the complexity of agency and self-awareness. They showcase different cognitive processes but do not diminish the existence of agency and the intricate nature of the self.
The Nature of Decision-Making: Habitual vs. Deliberative Control
Many decisions we make are either habitual, based on past experiences and learning, where we offload the decision-making to automatic systems, or they are made when we don't care much about the outcome. In cases where we face novel or crucial decisions, we engage in conscious deliberative control.
Motor Readiness Potentials and Brain Activity
Research on motor readiness potentials in the brain has raised questions about the timing of decision-making processes. While these potentials may indicate brain activity before conscious awareness, the interpretation of this phenomenon is debated. The complexity of neural processes and the significance of patterns over specific neural activities challenge reductionist views.
Consciousness and Self-Reflective Processes
The discussion delves into the mystery surrounding consciousness and the self-reflective nature of human cognition. It explores how our ability to model ourselves and think about our thoughts may give rise to consciousness. Different perspectives on the origins and nature of consciousness are raised, including considerations about crafting artificial intelligence systems that reflect human-like cognition.
Building an Intelligent Entity with Causal Knowledge
The podcast delves into the concept of building an agent that possesses actionable knowledge by interacting with the world and acquiring causal knowledge. It discusses the limitations of current AI systems, stating that they lack a world model and agency due to their disconnected nature. The episode explores the idea of creating intelligence through adaptive behavioral control that involves ongoing interaction with the environment, leading to intelligence with practical value in behavior.
Importance of Language in Thinking and Understanding
The discussion highlights the significance of language in shaping thought and enabling abstract thinking. It emphasizes how language allows for the manipulation of categorical entities, aiding in problem-solving and creative thought processes. The episode reflects on the evolution of thought and language, suggesting that language is fundamental for collaborative thinking and knowledge sharing among individuals, leading to cumulative intellectual growth and cultural evolution.
In this episode, Matt and Chris converse with Kevin Mitchell, an Associate Professor of Genetics and Neuroscience at Trinity College Dublin, and author of 'Free Agents: How Evolution Gave Us Free Will'.
We regret to inform you that the discussion does involve in-depth discussions of philosophy-adjacent topics such as free will, determinism, consciousness, the nature of self, and agency.
But do not let that put you off!
Kevin is a scientist and approaches them all through a sensible scientific perspective. You do not have to agree but you do have to pay attention!
If you ever wanted to see Matt geek out and Chris remain chill and be fully vindicated, this is the episode for you.
