Citizens need to actively participate in the political process and feel represented, which can be achieved through improved education, media literacy, and access to information.
Citizens' assemblies offer a means to inject deliberative and representative elements into decision-making, complementing existing elected institutions and fostering inclusive democracy.
Deep dives
Challenges in UK Democracy
The UK's democracy is falling short in terms of citizen participation, unequal participation among different groups, and inadequate representation. Participation in the democratic process is low, with many people only voting and not engaging further. Certain groups, such as the young and disadvantaged, participate less than others. Representation is also lacking, although there have been improvements for women and ethnic minorities. However, representation for those without university degrees has declined. In addition, policy failures and misjudged decision-making contribute to a lack of trust in the system. The balance of power between government and checks and balances is skewed, resulting in corruption and inadequate scrutiny. Furthermore, the democratic discourse often lacks thoughtful and evidenced-based discussions, hindering productive policy-making. These challenges are not unique to the UK and are present in many democracies around the world.
Importance of Citizens' Engagement and Values
Addressing the challenges in democracy requires a focus on citizens' engagement and values. Citizens need to actively participate in the political process and feel represented. Improved education about politics, media literacy, and reasoning can empower citizens with knowledge and skills to navigate the system effectively. Enhancing access to information, such as through a Democracy Information Hub, can make it easier for voters to find accurate and comprehensive information about elections, candidates, and policies. Preserving and reinforcing impartial public service institutions like the BBC is crucial for fostering informed political discourse. By combining efforts to engage citizens and improve knowledge, democratic systems can gradually shift towards a more inclusive and effective governance.
Harnessing the Potential of Citizens' Assemblies
Citizens' assemblies offer a promising approach to enhance democratic processes. These assemblies bring together randomly selected citizens to deliberate on critical issues, often with expert briefings to inform their discussions. They generate high-quality and thoughtful deliberations, resulting in coherent recommendations that align with the participants' underlying values. Citizens' assemblies can be used in various ways, such as shaping national debates on contentious issues, engaging citizens in legislative processes, and contributing to election and referendum campaigns. While concerns about accountability and potential biases exist, establishing oversight mechanisms and involving diverse perspectives in the assembly's facilitation can mitigate these risks. Citizens' assemblies offer a means to inject deliberative and representative elements into decision-making, complementing existing elected institutions.
Skepticism Towards Electoral Reform
While electoral reform is often considered a solution to the challenges in democracy, skepticism exists regarding its efficacy. Changing the electoral system faces significant barriers, as it affects politicians' personal interests and electoral dynamics. Additionally, every voting system has advantages and disadvantages. While proportional representation enhances fair and broader representation, it can also impede effective government formation, making it harder for voters to change those in power. Instead of relying solely on electoral reform, a comprehensive approach that combines multiple strategies, such as citizens' engagement, education, and media literacy, is more likely to bring incremental improvements to democracy. Balancing the incentives and structures within elected institutions is vital to create meaningful change.
In this episode we’re discussing elections, referenda, and how to fix our democracy, with none other than our long-time podcast host, Alan Renwick. In his inaugural lecture, Alan described democracy as rule for, and by, all, and suggested that the UK’s democratic system is falling short of that ideal. We discuss three suggested "fixes": electoral reform, improving citizen's access to reliable information, and the use of citizen's assemblies.
One of the central commitments in Prof Alan Renwick’s work is to the importance of the citizen, and our role in the democratic process. He is a leading expert on citizens assemblies, and his fourth book, Deliberative Mini-Publics examines how these can contribute to the policy process and even revitalise democracy. Most recently, Alan’s research examines the public’s attitudes about democracy, and democratic institutions, post Brexit.
Deliberative Mini-Publics: Core Design Features. Alan Renwick, Nicole Curato, David Farrell, Brigitte Geissel, Kimmo Grönlund, Patricia Mockler, Jean-Benoit Pilet, Jonathan Rose, Maija Setälä and Jane Suiter.
UCL’s Department of Political Science and School of Public Policy offers a uniquely stimulating environment for the study of all fields of politics, including international relations, political theory, human rights, public policy-making and administration. The Department is recognised for its world-class research and policy impact, ranking among the top departments in the UK on both the 2021 Research Excellence Framework and the latest Guardian rankings.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode