David Seymour: Why Treaty of Waitangi principles should be redefined
Feb 5, 2024
auto_awesome
David Seymour, Rahui Papa, Natalie Coates, and Maiki Sherman discuss redefining Treaty of Waitangi principles, addressing socioeconomic disparities, legal challenges to settlement, criticisms of proposed principles, social disparities faced by Maori, and the significance of Tinurangatilatanga in the Treaty of Waitangi.
The proposed Treaty of Waitangi principles bill has sparked controversy and opposition due to concerns about lack of consultation and potential impact on existing treaty settlements.
The interpretation and application of the Treaty of Waitangi principles have evolved over time, with recognition of partnership and reciprocity as key aspects.
Deep dives
Introduction to Treaty of Waitangi principles
The podcast episode explores the proposed Treaty of Waitangi principles bill and the ongoing debate about the interpretation and application of the Treaty. It highlights the importance of understanding the actual text of the Treaty and the significance of the treaty principles. The episode discusses how the principles have been used in legislative processes and how they have been interpreted by the courts and the Waitangi Tribunal. It also delves into the political dynamics surrounding the bill, including the positions of different political parties.
Origin and significance of the treaty principles
The podcast delves into the background of the treaty principles, explaining that they were created in the 1980s by the courts and later adopted by the government to guide decision-making on treaty-related matters. It outlines the key principles, such as the Crown's right to govern, Māori's right to use and control resources, equality before the law, cooperation, and redress for grievances. The podcast also highlights the evolving interpretation of the principles over time, including the recognition of partnership and reciprocity.
Contention over the proposed principles bill
The podcast focuses on the controversy surrounding the proposed treaty principles bill. It discusses concerns from Māori communities regarding the lack of consultation and potential impact on existing treaty settlements. It highlights how the bill has sparked large protests and strong opposition, with many arguing that it undermines the rights and protections guaranteed by the Treaty. The podcast also explores different political perspectives on the bill, including the National Party's cautious approach and New Zealand First's desire to clarify existing treaty principles.
Debating the interpretation and implementation of the treaty
The podcast dives into the wider debate around the interpretation and implementation of the treaty, including discussions about special or unique status for Māori, the importance of Tino Rangatiratanga, and the tension between majority rule and minority rights. It includes interviews and opinions from various political figures, legal experts, and Indigenous rights advocates, exploring different viewpoints on the subject. The podcast highlights the need for ongoing discussions and engagement to navigate the complex issues surrounding the Treaty of Waitangi.