Quillette Narrated

Ancient Indian Tradition—Or Twentieth-Century European Export?

Nov 20, 2025
Explore the complex origins of yoga as modern practices trace back to a 1924 Danish gymnastics manual. Hear personal stories of a guru hunt in Goa, and examine the influence of colonialism on Hatha Yoga. Discover how Krishnamacharya blended traditional methods with Western physical culture. The episode raises questions about cultural exchange, examines the debunked Yoga Kurunta myth, and reflects on how asanas evolved into a global phenomenon. Uncover the tensions between ancient roots and modern adaptations in today's yoga practices.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
ANECDOTE

First Yoga Lesson On Anjuna Beach

  • Carl von Siemens recounts finding a German teacher on Anjuna Beach teaching silent Ashtanga yoga.
  • He learns the lineage story linking Joyce, Krishnamacharya, Ramamohan Brahmachari and the fabled Yoga Kurunta.
INSIGHT

Patanjali Emphasizes Mind Over Posture

  • The Yoga Sutras define yoga primarily as mental cessation rather than gymnastic postures.
  • The Sutras mention asana only as a seat for meditation, not a catalogue of physical exercises.
INSIGHT

Modern Yoga Is A Cross-Cultural Product

  • Mark Singleton's research argues modern asana practice emerged from East–West exchanges in the 20th century.
  • Contemporary physical yoga likely grew through syncretic borrowing, not uninterrupted ancient continuity.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app