Childhood attachment, animal rights and the 'pit of despair': Harry Harlow's unethical experiments
Oct 22, 2022
auto_awesome
Exploring Harry Harlow's controversial experiments on childhood attachment and the importance of love and touch. Discussion on the 'pit of despair' and the lasting impact of isolation on monkeys. Highlighting the ethical concerns and the influence of Harlow's work on relationships and the animal rights movement.
Harry Harlow's experiments with monkeys demonstrated the importance of love and cuddles for healthy development, challenging the belief that touch did not matter.
Harlow's controversial experiments showed the profound effects of abusive relationships on social beings, contributing to the establishment of ethical standards in research and sparking the animal rights movement.
Deep dives
The Importance of Love and Cuddles for Babies
The prevailing wisdom a hundred years ago was that providing babies with love and affection would ruin them. The psychology books of the early 20th century focused on proximity rather than love between mother and child. However, American psychologist Harry Harlow conducted influential research on the necessity of affection and touch. Harlow's experiments with monkeys revealed the importance of love and cuddles for healthy development. The monkeys showed a clear preference for the cloth mother, even though the wire mother provided them with food. These findings challenged the belief that touch did not matter and reshaped the way psychologists worked with children. Harlow's work, while groundbreaking, was also ethically compromised, particularly towards the end of his career.
The Controversial Nature of Harlow's Experiments
Harlow's experiments involved creating inanimate surrogate mothers, including a wire mother and a cloth mother. The cloth mother provided emotional comfort and cuddling, while the wire mother provided nourishment. The experiments showed that the monkeys had a strong preference for the cloth mother, indicating that touch and affection were essential for their well-being. However, Harlow's later experiments crossed ethical lines, such as creating 'evil mothers' that rejected and mistreated the baby monkeys. These experiments revealed the profound effects of abusive relationships on social beings and provided important insights into child abuse. Despite their significance, these experiments faced backlash and sparked the animal rights movement.
Ethical Considerations and Paradigm Shifts
Harlow's controversial experiments contributed to the establishment of ethical standards in research. The American Animal Welfare Act was passed in 1969, and universities developed ethical review procedures through institutional review boards. These safeguards ensure that experiments involving living beings are evaluated for their ethical implications. Harlow's work, while influential, highlights the ethical dilemmas in research and the boundaries that should not be crossed. The knowledge gained from Harlow's studies revolutionized our understanding of animals' emotions and relationships, leading to a greater appreciation for their well-being. The evolution of ethical standards in research is an ongoing process that continues to shape the way scientific studies are conducted today.