Mountain & Prairie with Ed Roberson

Betsy Gaines Quammen - A Fascinating History of Public Lands in the West

Apr 28, 2022

01:07:55

Betsy Gaines Quammen is a historian and conservationist, and she’s also the author of the excellent book "American Zion: Cliven Bundy, God, & Public Lands in the West." Betsy has enjoyed a long career in the conservation world, working on issues ranging from grizzly bears in the West to fish in Mongolia to wildlife in East Africa. She also holds a doctorate in Environmental History from Montana State University, where her dissertation focused on the Mormon settlement of the West and public land conflicts. With such a depth of expertise on such a wide range of subjects, I was thrilled to have Betsy join me for a conversation about her book, public lands, and the West.

"American Zion" has been recommended to me numerous times since it was published in early 2020. Many of my most knowledgeable friends told me it was a must-read for anyone trying to make sense of the present-day threats to public lands here in the West. Well, I finally read it a few weeks ago, and I can confirm that my friends were correct– the book provided me with much-needed, nuanced context for understanding both specific public lands controversies and broader political threats. It also provided fascinating insights into the mindsets and goals of the Bundy family– the people behind the infamous occupation of Malheur Wildlife Refuge and the Battle of Bunkerville. I was also fascinated by the beliefs of the Bundys and their ancestors, and how their ideas about everything from religious texts to the US Constitution have influenced public discourse in the West and beyond.

Betsy and I connected last week and had a fun and educational conversation about everything from her career as a conservationist to her in-person interactions with the Bundy family. We started out discussing how she became interested in the West and why the Morman settlement of the West became the focus of her work. We discuss the Mormon prophets Joseph Smith and Brigham Young, and how and why Mormons settled in the West. We talked about how perceived persecution by the US government has served as a faith-building experience for the Bundys and their followers, and whether or not the Bundys truly believe the prophesies that they preach. We discuss the Sagebrush Rebellion, the Malheur takeover, the Battle of Bunkerville, and how Betsy thinks about her personal safety when writing about potentially violent people. She also talks about how "American Zion" was positively received by her Mormon friends, describes her current book project, and recommends tons of books that you’ll want to check out. Links to everything are in the episode notes.

It was great to finally have the opportunity to chat with Betsy, and I sincerely appreciate her taking the time. Hope you enjoy it as much as I did.

---

Betsy Gaines Quammen
American Zion: Cliven Bundy, God, & Public Lands in the West
Freeflow Institute (mention M&P for $100 off!)
Full Episode Notes with Links: https://mountainandprairie.com/betsy-gaines-quammen/

---

TOPICS DISCUSSED:

6:00 - Betsy reads her opening paragraph from her book American Zion
8:45 - Betsy explains how she became interested in the western US
10:00 - Betsy talks about why she began looking into Mormon history in the western states
14:45 - Betsy talks about her research and interactions regarding the Bundy family and their anti-federal government activities
22:00 - Betsy discusses the history of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints and how that impacted many rural attitudes towards land management and the federal government
27:00 - Betsy discusses her personal interactions with Cliven Bundy
31:00 - Betsy explains the depth of the Bundy’s faith and how that plays out in their political and anti-government action
31:30 – Betsy talks about the Bundys’ action after she published her book and explores the differences between the Malheur and Bunkerville incidents
34:00 – Betsy talks discusses the implications of her writing for her personal safety
35:45 – Betsy explains why any public land user should care about what the Bundys are doing.
40:45 – Betsy explains how anti-Semitism and the Sagebrush Rebellion laid the groundwork for the misinformation that is rampant today
46:00 - Betsy talks about how her book was received by her Mormon friends
50:30 - Betsy discusses her current work
52:45 - Betsy’s recommended books about the West
1:03:00 - Betsy’s parting words of wisdom