SPOS #924 – Coco Krumme On The Illusion Of Optimization
Mar 24, 2024
auto_awesome
Coco Krumme discusses the illusion of optimization, exploring its influence in society and the trade-offs it brings. She offers a unique perspective from running a distillery to flying a small airplane. The podcast dives into the history of optimization, its impact on various aspects of life, and the complexity of efficiency with significant trade-offs. The chapter descriptions cover redefining optimization, unintended consequences, balancing discipline, and a reflective encounter at Perito Moreno Glacier.
Optimization extends beyond math to influence diverse areas like recipes, systems, and human connections.
Excessive optimization results in fragility, homogenization, and disconnection, highlighting the need for balance.
Deep dives
Accessible Thought Leaders at Affordable Prices
Organizations can now access personalized thought leadership video experiences easily at reasonable prices on thinkersone.com. These experiences provide at least 15 minutes of content from renowned thinkers like Tom Peters, Rita McGrath, and more, enhancing everyday meetings and events.
Rethinking Optimization: Expansive Definition and Lemonade
The podcast guest challenges traditional views of optimization, highlighting its broad sense beyond mathematical techniques. Using the example of optimizing a lemonade recipe based on preferences, constraints, and ingredients cost, the process illustrates the complexity beyond simple formulas.
Losses Due to Over-Optimization: Slack, Place, Scale
The guest identifies three types of losses resulting from excessive optimization: reduced redundancies and downtime leading to fragility, homogenization of diverse systems impacting agriculture, and disconnection from the thorough understanding of products like lemonade or baked goods.
Balancing Optimization with Human Connection and Practices
Maintaining a balance between optimization and human connection involves shifting perspectives towards understanding the lost elements like downtime, interconnection between parts and wholes, and the importance of reevaluating shortcuts taken in modern conveniences.
Welcome to episode #924 of Six Pixels of Separation - The ThinkersOne Podcast.
Here it is: Six Pixels of Separation - The ThinkersOne Podcast - Episode #924. In her new book, Optimal Illusions - The False Promise of Optimization, Coco Krumme embarks on a compelling journey to unravel the influence of optimization in our society. Coco's diverse pursuits - from running a craft distillery on a rural island to making sculptures and flying a small airplane - give her analysis a unique perspective (far removed from the standard academic fare on the subject). With that, she is an applied mathematician with an impressive background, including a Ph.D. from MIT and significant experience in academia and tech. Optimization, a principle initially rooted in mathematical theory, has dramatically reshaped our world. It dictates everything from the efficiency of airline schedules to the algorithmic matches on dating sites to how we figure out our best days. Optimal Illusions is a fascinating read, as Coco explores the history of optimization, highlighting its journey from America's founding principles to its application by oil tycoons, wildlife ecologists, Silicon Valley technocrats, lifestyle gurus, and beyond. This exploration reveals a complexity where the quest for efficiency - while yielding undeniable benefits - has also led to significant trade-offs, compromising resilience, limiting options, and narrowing perspectives. Coco's work in scientific computation provides her with an intimate understanding of the pitfalls of optimization's reach. She argues that while optimization may offer short-term gains in efficiency, it ultimately fosters a society that is less adaptable and more homogenous. The book challenges readers to consider the hidden costs of optimization - from the erosion of human creativity and flexibility to the potential for creating systems that are fragile and prone to failure. For anyone intrigued by the intersection of technology, society, and human behavior, this episode is for you. Enjoy the conversation...