ccTLD warning and auction clawbacks – DNW Podcast #513
Dec 16, 2024
auto_awesome
John Berryhill, an attorney specializing in domain name law, shares valuable insights about the complexities and legal challenges surrounding country code domains. He discusses Stuart Lawley's lasting influence on the industry and the nuances of ccTLDs, highlighting their vulnerability to political shifts. Berryhill also dives into an intriguing lawsuit involving GoDaddy's auction clawbacks, shedding light on the legal intricacies affecting new domain owners. Tune in for a mix of personal anecdotes and critical industry knowledge!
John Berryhill reflects on Stuart Lawley's profound influence in the domain industry and the legacy he leaves behind after his passing.
The podcast emphasizes the risks associated with ccTLDs, highlighting the need for due diligence due to changing local policies affecting ownership stability.
Deep dives
Reflection on Stuart Lawley
John Berryhill shares his memories of Stuart Lawley, the late CEO of ICM Registry, highlighting Lawley's determination and impact on the domain industry. Berryhill recounts how Lawley's encouragement led him to start his own legal practice, reflecting on their collaborative moments and Lawley's resilience in facing opposition during his career. He recalls a significant meeting in San Francisco, where Lawley dealt with protests against the.XX domain, showcasing his ability to navigate challenges. The emotional responses from various individuals after Lawley’s passing underline the significant legacy he leaves behind in the domain world.
Understanding Country Code Domains
The complexities surrounding country code top-level domains (ccTLDs) are discussed, particularly the potential for rule changes that can impact ownership and registration. Berryhill emphasizes that while domains like.io might be popular, their stability is subject to the policies of the local governing body, which can change over time. He points out historical examples of ccTLDs that have undergone significant shifts due to political factors, illustrating how these domains can fluctuate in value and usability. This serves as a caution for domain registrants to thoroughly understand the implications of the ccTLDs they choose.
Clawback Lawsuit Against GoDaddy
The ongoing lawsuit involving GoDaddy concerning the clawback of domains like calor.com and butane.com raises critical questions about ownership rights and the responsibilities of registrars. Two buyers who won the auctions are now pursuing legal action after their domains were reclaimed post-purchase, which has left them in a perplexing situation after they had already begun plans for their respective domains. Berryhill outlines the uncertainties surrounding the domain registrations and the contracts involved, suggesting that the outcome may hinge on specific contractual interpretations. The case also highlights broader issues within the domain industry regarding registry practices and the enforcement of contractual agreements.
Challenges in Domain Registrations
The discussion highlights the unpredictable nature of domain registrations and the potential risks that can arise, particularly with ccTLDs and the policies governing their usage. Berryhill notes that issues can arise due to arbitrary changes in rules and the lack of transparency in domains’ management, which can leave registrants vulnerable. He stresses the importance of due diligence when selecting domain names, including understanding the jurisdictional nuances associated with various ccTLDs. The overall message is clear: domain investors must remain vigilant and informed about the regulatory environment to protect their investments.
John Berryhill explains why you should be cautious of country code domains and discusses an auction clawback lawsuit. Attorney John Berryhill joins us on today’s show. John explains how Stuart Lawley, who passed away recently, helped John take the step to start his own law practice. Then we talk about country code domain names and […]