The McShay Show Week 11 Reactions: Alabama Rolls, Oregon Escapes, & Heis-Mendoza! | The McShay Show
Nov 9, 2025
Todd McShay is joined by Steve Muench, a college football analyst known for his insightful film evaluations. They break down Alabama's dominant performance against LSU, highlighting Ty Simpson's growth. Indiana's thrilling upset win, led by Fernando Mendoza's clutch play, is explored, as well as Oregon's narrow escape at Iowa with a critical throw by Dante Moore. The duo also discusses current Heisman contenders and Texas Tech's impressive defense, showcasing the vibrant game day atmosphere in Lubbock.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Parenting Lesson After A Tough Game
- Todd McShay describes bonding with his son after a tough high school game and talking about life, leadership, and handling interceptions with head high.
- He frames tough parenting days as learning opportunities and finds wins in small moments away from football.
High School Football's Wild, Charming Moments
- Todd and Steve highlight quirky, heartfelt high-school and West Texas football moments, from a coach standing on a building to a late-night coin flip at a gas station.
- They celebrate the culture and community that make local football memorable beyond wins and losses.
Alabama's Identity Is Defense And Simpson's Poise
- Todd and Steve argue Alabama's defense and Ty Simpson's growth matter more than flashes, highlighting run-game concerns despite offensive weapons.
- They note Simpson's mechanics and pocket play as pro-level traits that stabilize Alabama's season.
