Are You Tired of Feeling Cynical? Hopeful Skepticism Could Be a Way Out
Jan 31, 2025
auto_awesome
In a thought-provoking discussion, Jamil Zaki, a Stanford psychologist and author of Hope for Cynics, tackles the pervasive cynicism that many feel today. He uncovers how cynicism can erode social connections and well-being. Zaki introduces the concept of hopeful skepticism, a flexible mindset that embraces evidence while appreciating humanity's positive aspects. He also explores strategies to foster genuine connections in an increasingly lonely world, challenging listeners to rethink their outlook and strengthen their social bonds.
Cynicism's rise correlates with declining trust in institutions, driving a widespread negativity that can be countered by hopeful skepticism.
Hopeful skepticism encourages openness to new information, enabling individuals to challenge negative assumptions and recognize human kindness.
Deep dives
The Rise of Cynicism in Society
Cynicism, defined as the belief that people are inherently selfish and untrustworthy, has been steadily increasing over the last few decades. In 1972, about half of Americans felt they could trust most people, whereas by 2018, this number had dwindled to one-third. This decline in trust parallels a broader disillusionment with institutions such as government, media, and education, which many believe have contributed to a general sense of negativity. Factors such as the consumption of negative news—especially on social media—fuel perceptions that the world and humanity are worsening, reinforcing a cycle of cynicism among individuals.
Cynicism vs. Hopeful Skepticism
The podcast discusses a critical distinction between cynicism and hopeful skepticism. While cynics tend to view themselves as more astute and realistic about human behavior, research shows that they often perform worse on cognitive tasks and in interpersonal judgments. This stems from an inclination to seek only confirming evidence for their negative beliefs rather than considering broader perspectives. In contrast, hopeful skepticism involves maintaining an openness to new information, allowing individuals to adapt and recognize the positive aspects of human behavior.
Practical Steps to Combat Cynicism
To counteract cynicism, individuals can adopt strategies that encourage positive engagement with others. Key actions include actively challenging negative assumptions and seeking evidence to support a more balanced view of humanity. Additionally, practicing 'positive gossip'—sharing instances of human kindness—can shift focus from negative experiences to positive interactions. By fostering these habits, individuals not only enhance their own outlook but also contribute to a more hopeful and connected community.
It’s easy to be cynical about the state of the world—even when you’re a researcher who studies empathy and kindness. Stanford University psychologist Jamil Zaki turned his own negativity into his new book Hope for Cynics: The Surprising Science of Human Goodness. The book busts common myths about cynicism and explores what it could be doing to our body and brain. Zaki reflects on the imperfections of cynicism and hope and presents a third option: hopeful skepticism.
E-mail us at sciencequickly@sciam.com if you have any questions, comments or ideas for stories we should cover!
Discover something new every day: subscribe to Scientific American and sign up for Today in Science, our daily newsletter.
Science Quickly is produced by Rachel Feltman, Fonda Mwangi, Kelso Harper, Madison Goldberg and Jeff DelViscio. This episode was hosted by Rachel Feltman. Our show is edited by Fonda Mwangi with fact-checking by Shayna Posses and Aaron Shattuck. The theme music was composed by Dominic Smith.