The podcast discusses the effectiveness of psychodynamic psychotherapy and cognitive behavioral therapy for treating depression. It explores the challenges of conducting studies on therapy, expresses skepticism towards Freudian theories, and highlights the importance of talking about personal issues. The chapter also compares the effectiveness of CBT and psychotherapy and recommends exploring these options for individuals with depression symptoms.
Psychodynamic therapy has a large effect on treating mental disorders, offering insights into unconscious thoughts and desires.
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) is considered the gold standard of psychotherapy, focusing on irrational thought patterns and improving overall well-being.
Both psychodynamic therapy and CBT are more effective than control conditions, but further research and replication are needed to solidify the evidence base.
Deep dives
Effectiveness of Psychodynamic Therapy
A meta-analysis of 27 studies on psychodynamic therapy reveals that it has a large effect on treating mental disorders. The studies show that psychotherapy, based on theories originally developed by Freud, is effective in improving symptoms and overall well-being. Despite initial skepticism, the evidence suggests that this therapy approach helps individuals gain insights into unconscious thoughts and desires, and how they impact their lives. The therapy involves exploring conflicts between the unconscious and lived experiences and helps alleviate mental health issues.
Effectiveness of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) is considered the gold standard of psychotherapy and has been extensively studied. A meta-analysis of 409 randomized controlled trials, involving over 52,000 patients, demonstrates the effectiveness of CBT. The analysis shows that CBT has a significant impact in treating mental disorders, with an effect size of 0.79 standard deviation on average. This type of therapy focuses on identifying and addressing irrational thought patterns and restructuring cognitive processes. It emphasizes helping individuals develop practical strategies to manage their thoughts and improve overall well-being.
Comparing Treatments to Control Conditions
Both psychodynamic therapy and cognitive behavioral therapy have shown to be more effective than control conditions in treating mental health issues. The meta-analyses reveal that both approaches lead to better outcomes compared to inactive control conditions. However, when considering the risk of bias, the number of high-quality studies is relatively smaller, impacting the overall effect sizes. It is important to note that publication bias may influence reported effect sizes, highlighting the need for further research and replication to solidify the evidence base for psychotherapy interventions.
Psychotherapy efficacy: CBT and psychodynamic therapy work
The podcast discusses the findings of a meta-analysis on the efficacy of psychotherapy, focusing on cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and psychodynamic therapy. The analysis shows that both therapies have evidence to support their effectiveness, with CBT having better overall evidence. However, the difference in effectiveness between the two therapies is not statistically significant. This suggests that talking to a skilled and empathetic therapist, regardless of the specific therapeutic approach, can have a positive impact on mental health.
CBT compared to drugs and other therapies
The podcast highlights that CBT is comparable to antidepressant medication in the short term but more effective in the long term (6-12 months). Combining CBT with medication does not yield better results than CBT alone. When comparing CBT to other therapies, including psychodynamic therapy, the meta-analysis shows that there is no clear superiority of CBT. While CBT has a larger effect size, the difference is not statistically significant. This suggests that CBT may not be inherently better than other therapies, and individual preferences and needs should be considered when choosing a treatment approach.
What treatment works best for people with depression? Is it psychodynamic psychotherapy, in the Freudian tradition, with its emphasis on hidden, unconscious desires? Or is it Cognitive Behavioural Therapy, based on more contemporary (and less, y’know, made up) ways of thinking about psychology? How do you even do a good study on something as complicated as psychological therapy, anyway?
In this episode of The Studies Show, Tom (ego) and Stuart (superego) talk about two recent reviews that summarise all the evidence on which kind of therapy works best - and find some results that surprise them both.
The Studies Show is sponsored by Works in Progress magazine - a journal of new and exciting ideas about how to make the world better. Recent issues have covered topics as varied as geothermal power, architecture, the scientific literature, vaccines, and cocktails - explaining how we’ve made progress with them in the past, and how we might improve them even more in future. Find all their articles for free at this link.
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.thestudiesshowpod.com/subscribe
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
