18Forty Podcast Ammiel Hirsch: How To Understand Reform Judaism’s Anti-Zionist Crisis [Denominations Bonus Episode]
Jul 2, 2024
Rabbi Ammiel Hirsch, a prominent leader in the Reform Movement, dives into the layers of anti-Zionism within his community. He discusses the growing disconnect of younger Jews from Israel and the implications for Jewish continuity. The conversation touches on the need for open dialogue between caring for fellow Jews and addressing global issues. Hirsch also reflects on the challenges of fostering a strong Jewish identity, especially post-October 7th, underscoring the importance of leadership and community engagement in navigating these complex dynamics.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Peoplehood Is Core To Continuity
- Jewish peoplehood and Ahavat Yisrael are central to American Jewish continuity.
- If Americans lose connection to Israel, Jewish identity and long-term continuity weaken.
Tikkun Olam Needs Peoplehood
- Non-Orthodox diaspora Judaism emphasized universal tikkun olam, which drifted from Jewish particularism.
- Without anchoring universalism in peoplehood, Jewish universalism becomes generic universalism.
Generational View Of Israel Has Shifted
- Younger American Jews grew up with less sense of existential threat and see Israel differently.
- Many now view Israel as a powerful actor rather than an endangered national home, fueling alienation.
