"The Cognitive Revolution" | AI Builders, Researchers, and Live Player Analysis

Is a US-China Thucydides Trap Unavoidable? With David C. Kang from the ChinaTalk Podcast

129 snips

Apr 13, 2025

David C. Kang, Professor of international relations at USC and author, challenges Western views on East Asian geopolitics. He argues that a stable regional system has existed for centuries, emphasizing internal dynamics over external conflicts in U.S.-China relations. Guests Jordan Schneider and Ilari Michaela add depth by exploring historical perspectives, including Vietnam's quest for independence and the civil service exam's role in promoting stability. Their discussion critiques the Thucydides Trap theory, suggesting a more nuanced understanding of power dynamics in East Asia.

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Books

Transcript

Episode notes

INSIGHT

Internal Challenges

Great powers often stumble due to internal issues, not external threats.
This historical pattern applies to both the US and China today.

INSIGHT

East Asian Peace

East Asian states formed around the first millennium.
Since then, land-grab wars, common in European history, are rare in East Asia.

INSIGHT

Threats to China

Conventional wisdom suggests China built the Great Wall to defend against smaller nomadic groups.
This contradicts IR theory, which posits larger countries threaten smaller ones.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

China Transformed

Historical Change and the Limits of European Experience

Roy Bin Wong

In *China Transformed*, Roy Bin Wong offers a bold and intellectually ambitious exploration of China's historical development in comparison to Europe. The book challenges the assumption that Europe provides a universal model of development, instead advocating for a more nuanced understanding that incorporates both European and Sinocentric perspectives. Wong's work highlights themes such as state-making and popular action, providing a sophisticated discussion of imperial and modern China.

Beyond Power Transitions

U.S.-China Relations and International Order

Xinru Ma

David C. Kang

Boundless Winds of Empire, Rhetoric and Ritual in Early Chosun Diplomacy with Ming China

Rhetoric and Ritual in Early Chosŏn Diplomacy with Ming China

Sixiang Wang

Sixiang Wang's "Boundless Winds of Empire" offers a nuanced exploration of early Chosun Korea's diplomatic relationship with Ming China. The book challenges traditional narratives by focusing on the cultural practices and rhetorical strategies employed by Korean elites. Wang masterfully weaves together diverse sources, including poetry and official records, to reveal the agency of Korean actors in shaping Sino-Korean relations. He demonstrates how seemingly routine diplomatic rituals were crucial in constructing and maintaining a complex political order. The book's insightful analysis sheds light on the dynamics of power, identity, and cultural exchange in early modern East Asia.

Shoal of Time

A History of the Hawaiian Islands

Gavan Daws

In 'Shoal of Time: A History of the Hawaiian Islands,' Gavan Daws provides a detailed and engaging history of Hawaii. The book covers the islands' early Polynesian settlement, the impact of European and American contact, the overthrow of the Hawaiian monarchy, and the subsequent annexation by the United States. Daws's work is renowned for its thorough research and insightful analysis, making it a valuable resource for understanding the complex and rich history of Hawaii.

Beyond the Bronze Pillars

Liam Kelly