Elon Musk's polarizing ascent in the MAGA movement
Feb 27, 2025
auto_awesome
Gabby del Valle, a policy reporter for The Verge, shares her firsthand insights from CPAC, where Elon Musk's surprising appearance stirred up tensions. The discussion dives into the intricate relationship between Musk and Trump, revealing mixed feelings among MAGA supporters about Musk's influence on the right-wing movement. Gabby highlights the concerns regarding technology's role in nationalism, along with the ideological rifts within conservative circles. Expect a wild ride through chainsaws, Dogecoin, and the complexities of the evolving MAGA vision.
Elon Musk's surprising elevation in the MAGA movement reflects a growing enthusiasm among right-wing supporters showcased during the CPAC event.
Attendees displayed a complex skepticism toward big tech, viewing it as both a potential threat and a tool for advancing conservative goals.
Deep dives
The Impact of Musk and Trump on Right-Wing Politics
The evolving relationship between Elon Musk and Donald Trump appears to significantly influence the current direction of the right-wing political movement in the U.S. Observations from the Annual Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) highlighted the enthusiasm among attendees for both figures. Musk's surprise appearance, characterized by antics such as brandishing a chainsaw on stage, indicated his rising status within the MAGA community, suggesting that he shares the platform with Trump rather than being overshadowed by him. Attendees expressed admiration for Musk's endeavors while also observing a complex dynamic where both Elon and Trump maintain their respective fan bases despite occasional conflicts.
Changing Dynamics at CPAC
Attendance at CPAC has notably decreased, yet the energy and enthusiasm among diehard supporters have intensified. Journalists and attendees noted that while the crowd size may have diminished, the passion for speakers like Trump and Musk remains high, indicating a committed base. Additionally, the ideological landscape is shifting, as attendees from diverse backgrounds including traditional conservatives and tech enthusiasts converge, creating an atmosphere where various viewpoints coexist, albeit sometimes contentiously. This coalition allows these factions to align under shared objectives while also revealing underlying tensions regarding the movement's future direction.
Perceptions of Big Tech and Future Policy
Attendees at CPAC exhibited a consistent skepticism toward big tech, aligning with views expressed by influential figures like Steve Bannon. The sentiment framed big tech leaders as 'techno-feudalists' who exploit taxpayer funds for personal gain, particularly in light of their association with concerns like free speech restrictions. While Trump and Musk are perceived to represent the interests of this movement, the overall approach seems more focused on dismantling perceived liberal biases within federal agencies than on generating a supportive environment for tech innovations. Thus, the push to 'break up big tech' underscores a broader skepticism regarding the role of technology in governance.
Contradictions Within the MAGA Movement
The conservative dialogue at CPAC revealed a fascinating contradiction where admiration for innovation coexists with deep-seated fears about its implications. Many attendees grappled with concepts like Neuralink and the broader impacts of AI, indicating an apprehension towards rapid technological advances that may threaten traditional values. This dissonance is critical as it highlights divergence among attendees who see tech as both a potential avenue for progress and a risk to their way of life. Therefore, as the movement seeks to unify various factions, these underlying tensions concerning technology's role may shape its political strategies in the coming years.
This is Alex Heath, deputy editor of The Verge. I’m guest hosting today’s episode while Nilay is still away for a much-needed vacation. He’ll be back next week. But today, we’re diving into the bromance between Elon Musk and Donald Trump, and more specifically, how it’s impacting the changing right-wing political movement here in the United States.
There’s no better place to get that temperature check than CPAC. Musk showed up there this year for a wild interview — you may have seen clips of him waving around a literal chainsaw. Thankfully, Verge policy Gaby del Valle was on the ground this year, and as you’ll hear her say, she barely slept. But she got a front-row look at how the world of MAGA really feels about Elon, DOGE, and regulating Big Tech.
Links:
I cannot describe how strange Elon Musk’s CPAC appearance was | Verge
At CPAC, the world’s populists parrot the leader who inspired them | Politico
Government still threatening to ‘semi-fire’ workers who don’t answer Musk email | Verge