Caleb Ontiveros presents a compelling case for Stoicism, suggesting it's more intuitive than we realize. He questions why we let major setbacks affect us when minor ones don’t. The discussion highlights the link between happiness and virtue, emphasizing that true contentment arises from our character, not external events. It also explores the complex dynamics of suffering and joy, arguing that real fulfillment isn’t found in wealth or pleasure, but in the strength of our internal values.
Stoicism emphasizes that true happiness is grounded in cultivating virtue and character, independent of external circumstances or pleasures.
The podcast argues that significant setbacks should not dictate one's happiness, as minor obstacles do not devastate our lives either.
Deep dives
The Essence of a Happy Life
A key tenet of Stoicism is the belief that happiness stems from cultivating excellent character and virtue, rather than external circumstances or pleasures. This concept suggests that individuals have complete control over their happiness by making virtuous choices and sound judgments. The Stoics argue that happiness is accessible to everyone, as it is based on internal qualities rather than variable external factors. Thus, true happiness is understood to be stable and independent of life's ups and downs.
Challenging Common Perceptions of Setbacks
The podcast questions why larger setbacks, which can seem overwhelming, are often granted more power over one's happiness compared to minor inconveniences. It highlights the Stoic belief that while life presents numerous challenges, such as loss or adversity, none should dictate overall life satisfaction. By touching on the simple observation that small obstacles do not ruin a life, the discussion encourages listeners to reevaluate how they view more significant negative events. The fundamental assertion is that happiness must not depend on external circumstances, as exemplified by Marcus Aurelius' perspective on perception and complaint.
The Role of Internal Character
Stoicism also posits that positive experiences, like wealth or pleasure, do not inherently create happiness, as the key determinant lies in one's character and internal state. The podcast emphasizes that even positive outcomes must be evaluated through the lens of virtue; otherwise, they could lead to misguided pursuits. This view challenges the notion that accumulating positive experiences equates to a fulfilling life, further reinforcing the premise that character should take precedence. Ultimately, the inquiry raises critical questions about what truly sustains happiness, urging a shift in focus from external achievements to internal development.
Caleb Ontiveros makes the case that Stoicism is more intuitive than you might think. He argues that if minor setbacks don't ruin our lives, why should major ones? This episode explores how Stoic ideas about virtue, happiness, and adversity align with our deepest intuitions about living well.
***
Subscribe to The Stoa Letter for weekly meditations, actions, and links to the best Stoic resources: www.stoaletter.com/subscribe
Download the Stoa app (it’s a free download): https://stoameditation.com/pod
If you try the Stoa app and find it useful, but truly cannot afford it, email us and we'll set you up with a free account.