Guns Part 1: The Sudden Celebrity of Sir John Knight
Aug 31, 2023
auto_awesome
Jonathan Barry, a historian at the University of Exeter, dives into the unexpected fame of 17th-century nobleman Sir John Knight. This deep exploration reveals how Knight's influence has shaped modern American gun culture. The discussion covers the complexities of historical perception, examining his contentious legacy and its echoes in today’s gun rights debates. Barry highlights the intricate dynamics between historical statutes and contemporary legal contexts, making the case for how past narratives continue to impact current public sentiments on gun ownership.
The Sir John Knight case, often celebrated as a hero of gun rights, was primarily about his bigoted beliefs and fear of a Catholic conspiracy, rather than the right to bear arms.
The British perspective on the Sir John Knight case challenges the notion that it symbolizes a significant precedent for individual gun rights, due to Knight's compliance with gun control laws and lack of evidence suggesting he carried arms into Bristol.
Deep dives
The Sir John Knight Case and Its Relevance to Gun Rights
The podcast explores the significance of the Sir John Knight case in the context of American gun rights. Although Knight is often celebrated as a hero of gun rights, a closer examination reveals a different story. Knight's case had little to do with the right to bear arms, as he willingly adhered to gun control laws, checking his weapons at the door of a church and abiding by the bylaws of Bristol. Moreover, his case was primarily about his bigoted beliefs and fear of a Catholic conspiracy in Bristol. The government, in fact, did not want to prosecute Knight and would have preferred an apology. The Supreme Court, in its landmark ruling in the New York State rifle and pistol association V. Bruin case, chooses to cherry-pick history and minimize Knight's flaws in order to support their predetermined stance on gun rights.
A Different Perspective on the Sir John Knight Case
While some argue that the Sir John Knight case affirms the individual right to bear arms, others, like British history experts, find this claim dubious. Knight's compliance with strict gun control laws, his checking of weapons at the church entrance, and the absence of evidence suggesting he carried arms into Bristol challenge the notion that his case symbolizes a significant precedent for individual gun rights. The British perspective tends to downplay the importance of the right to bear arms, reflecting their society's stronger reliance on state protection and historically lower firearm-related violence compared to the U.S.
Focusing on Irrelevant Stories in the Gun Rights Debate
The podcast acknowledges falling into the trap of discussing irrelevant stories and focusing on characters like Sir John Knight in the gun rights debate. It suggests a shift in the conversation by exploring different angles, including shooting guns in North Carolina, visiting an Alabama resident with a unique perspective, and reevaluating the assassination of Robert Kennedy. This approach aims to redirect the dialogue to more relevant aspects of gun violence and its societal impact.
The Complex Character of Sir John Knight
The podcast provides insight into the character of Sir John Knight, exposing his unlikable qualities. Knight was a vindictive, spiteful, and bigoted individual who deliberately stirred up trouble and had involvement in the slave trade. These characteristics make him an unlikely hero figure for those championing American liberty and question his celebration as a symbol of gun rights.
In the battles over gun rights, a shadowy English nobleman from the 17th century has unexpectedly taken center stage. Who was he? What did he do that has — 300 years later — endeared him to a generation of legal scholars? Revisionist History explores the cult of personality around the mysterious Sir John Knight.
Sign up for Pushkin+ on the Revisionist History Apple Show page or at Pushkin.fm to binge the entire series now!
