Ep 159 - The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas and The Forbidden Words of Margaret A (Bonus Episode)
Feb 5, 2016
57:47
auto_awesome Snipd AI
Hosts discuss two science fiction stories and delve into feminist writing and the role of humor in writing. They explore the festival and the dark secret in one of the stories, and discuss the moral cost of sacrifice. They also explore the concept of scapegoats and the theme of censorship in another story, and touch on self-censorship in journalism and its consequences for controversial stories.
Read more
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas raises ethical questions about sacrificing one life for the happiness of many.
The Forbidden Words of Margaret A. explores self-censorship, freedom of speech, and power dynamics between government and media.
Both stories highlight the challenges faced by journalists in environments of government control, commercial and political pressures, and the distortion of memory during reporting.
Deep dives
The City of Happiness and the Price of Guilt
The story explores a city called Omalas where everyone is extremely happy, but the happiness comes at the cost of keeping a feeble-minded child locked in a basement. Some people choose to walk away from the city, questioning the morality of sacrificing one life for the happiness of many.
The Forbidden Words of Margaret A
In a dystopian future, a woman named Margaret A is locked up and forbidden from speaking due to the controversial and divisive nature of her words. Journalists are allowed periodic visits to her, but their access and reporting are heavily censored by the government. The story raises questions about self-censorship, freedom of speech, and the power dynamics between the government and the media.
Journalistic Self-Censorship and Freedom of the Press
The story reflects on the challenges faced by journalists in an environment of self-censorship enforced by the government. It highlights the tension between the government's control over the narrative and the journalists' desire to uncover the truth and provide objective reporting. The story raises concerns about the influence of commercial and political pressures on journalistic integrity.
Unreliability of Memory and the Impact on Reporting
The story touches on the theme of memory and its impact on reporting. The journalist struggles to accurately paraphrase Margaret A's words due to the passage of time and the fading of memories. This highlights the challenges of conveying complex ideas and the potential for distortion when relying on memory and personal interpretation.
The Cost of Truth and Rebellion
Both stories explore the cost of seeking truth and challenging oppressive systems. In the first story, individuals must confront their guilt and make the choice to give up their happiness in the face of injustice. In the second story, the journalist grapples with the consequences of pursuing the truth and questioning authority. Both stories serve as a reminder of the importance of standing up for what is right, even when it comes at a personal cost.
For January's bonus episode, we put together a sci-fi double feature: The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas by Ursula K. Le Guin and The Forbidden Words of Margaret A. by L. Timmel Duchamp. Both are short stories of speculative fiction, and both are incredibly clever bummers.
When not despairing at the states of humanity and journalism, we lighten the mood with some horrifying mouth noises, David Brooks articles, and Andrew's campaign for Sexiest Man Alive.