237. The Great Famine: The Irish Exodus to America (Ep 2)
Mar 13, 2025
auto_awesome
Colm Tóibín, acclaimed Irish novelist and journalist, dives into the legacy of the Great Famine and its impact on Irish identity. He discusses the journey of famine refugees boarding 'coffin ships' and their shift in labor preferences upon arriving in America. Tóibín examines how Irish emigration laid the groundwork for powerful communities in cities like Boston and New York, influencing American politics today. The conversation also touches on the complex relationship between historical trauma and Irish nationalism, showcasing how these narratives resonate even in contemporary culture.
The Great Famine's legacy instigated a strong sense of Irish nationalism and political change, framing it as an act of oppression.
Irish emigrants sought new opportunities in America, leading to a politically active diaspora that shaped Irish identity and history.
Deep dives
The Long Impact of the Irish Famine
The Great Famine in Ireland, which began in the mid-1840s, persisted into the 1850s, and its effects lasted for decades afterward. This period of suffering saw not only deaths from starvation but also from diseases like typhus and dysentery, exacerbated by the overcrowding of those seeking relief. Initially, soup kitchens provided critical assistance, but the British government's decision to close these kitchens led to an even greater humanitarian crisis. As people gathered in search of food, their desperate conditions were vividly documented, yet political policies remained largely unchanged despite the grim realities.
Government Inaction and Public Perception
British authorities, particularly Charles Trevelyan, adopted a laissez-faire approach that was criticized for its insensitivity to the plight of the Irish. As relief efforts waned, stark descriptions of suffering emerged from journalists and observers, revealing the horror of starving populations. Yet, even faced with these accounts, government policy remained indifferent, often rooted in prejudiced views of the Irish as lazy or irresponsible. This disconnection between reality and policy not only deepened the suffering but also fostered resentment and a growing sentiment for political change among the Irish.
Emergence of Irish Nationalism
The Irish Famine catalyzed a sense of grievance that fueled nationalism and the desire for self-determination. Figures like John Mitchell and William Smith O'Brien articulated the anger and frustration with British governance, framing the Famine as a deliberate act of oppression rather than a natural disaster. Literary and political expressions began to reflect a national identity forged in the agony of this shared experience. Thus, the Famine became a pivotal point in Irish history, shaping the narrative of resistance and the movement toward eventual independence.
The Lasting Legacy of the Famine
The Famine's legacy extended beyond immediate survival, influencing socio-economic structures and public perceptions between Ireland and Britain for generations. The gradual transition from tenant farming to land ownership marked a significant reform spurred by British guilt over the devastation. This shift transformed the agricultural landscape, allowing for the emergence of a new class of farmers. Concurrently, Irish emigrants to America forged a powerful diaspora that became politically active, ensuring that the memory of the Famine and its repercussions continue to resonate in discussions of Irish identity and history.
The legacy of the Great Famine continues to shape not only Ireland, but the Irish diaspora in America, Canada, and the UK. In the mid-1800s, starving families fled the country in search of survival, gathering at the docks to board “coffins ships” sailing to Liverpool and the east coast of the USA. When “the famine Irish” arrived in America they resented the idea of ever doing rural work again, and sought work in the police, in bars, and in the fire brigade. Irish communities centred around Boston, New York, and Philadelphia developed into powerful Irish congresses in politics. How does the legacy of famine emigration continue to shape American politics today?
Listen as William and Anita are joined once again by writer and historian Colm Tóibín to discuss the Great Famine and how it shaped post-modern Irishness, from the cheekiness of The Beatles to Donald Trump’s cabinet.
_____________
Empire UK Live Tour: The podcast is going on a UK tour! William and Anita will be live on stage in Glasgow, Birmingham, York and Bristol, discussing how the British Empire continues to shape our everyday lives. Tickets are on sale NOW, to buy yours head to empirepoduk.com.
Empire Club: Become a member of the Empire Club to receive early access to miniseries, ad-free listening, early access to live show tickets, bonus episodes, book discounts, and a weekly newsletter! Head to empirepoduk.com to sign up.