73: Romance Was Never Real: From Courtly Love to the Rise of the Fuckboy feat. Sabrina Strings
Oct 12, 2024
auto_awesome
Sabrina Strings, a UC Santa Barbara professor and author of "The End of Love," joins the discussion to explore the complex intertwining of race, gender, and romance. She critiques how historical notions of love, from courtly ideals to modern realities, perpetuate societal inequalities. The conversation delves into the harmful archetype of the 'fuckboy' and its roots in media portrayals, challenging listeners to rethink romantic norms. Strings emphasizes the need for an evolved understanding of love that defies traditional constraints and embraces inclusivity.
Romanticism is critiqued as a cultural construct that perpetuates male dominance, obscuring women's realities and hindering their empowerment.
Media representations play a crucial role in shaping societal expectations of relationships, often commodifying women and limiting their roles in romance.
Examining personal dating narratives reveals broader societal issues, particularly for marginalized identities, highlighting the challenges faced by Black women in contemporary dating.
Deep dives
Romanticism as a Tool of Male Power
Romanticism is viewed as a cultural construct that serves to perpetuate male dominance by obscuring women's realities. As articulated by Shulamith Firestone, the notion of romance can keep women unaware of their societal conditions. This perspective emphasizes that romantic ideals can be detrimental, as they might encourage women to pursue romantic relationships without understanding the power dynamics involved. Recognizing romanticism as a tool for male power allows for a deeper discussion on how women can reclaim their narratives away from traditional romantic constructs.
The Impact of Media on Dating Ideals
Media representations play a significant role in shaping perceptions of desirability and relationships, particularly through the lens of men's perspectives on women's roles. Historical analysis shows that media, especially men's magazines, project notions of ideal femininity that often reduce women to objects of desire. This commodification can lead to the internalization of limited standards of beauty and behavior among women. By analyzing these media influences, one can understand the constraints they place on both women and men's expectations in romantic contexts.
Personal Narratives as Catalysts for Understanding
The genesis of new works often stems from personal experiences and narratives that resonate with broader societal themes. The connection between personal dating experiences and the cultural critique of romance serves to amplify the issues faced by marginalized identities, particularly Black women. By documenting these dating disasters and reflecting on personal encounters, there emerges an opportunity for deeper examination of how societal pressures shape individual romantic experiences. Ultimately, these narratives can reveal the systemic issues inherent in contemporary dating cultures.
The Challenge of the 'Romantic Ideal'
The concept of the 'romantic ideal' is critiqued for establishing unrealistic standards for relationships, largely solidified by historical narratives and societal expectations. The ideal paints a picture of romantic love as a noble pursuit, while simultaneously enforcing passive femininity and active masculinity. Throughout history, these narratives have marginalized discussions about desire, complicating the understanding of what true intimacy and partnership might entail. Dismantling the romantic ideal opens avenues for reconsidering love outside the confines of traditional romantic structures.
The Historical Context of Dating Dynamics
Understanding historical contexts reveals the roots of contemporary dating dynamics, particularly regarding race and class. Black women's bodies have been historically viewed as commodities, resulting in unique challenges when navigating dating and romantic relationships. This framework illustrates how societal biases manifest in modern dating practices, often relegating Black women to lower desirability on dating apps. Therefore, the examination of these historical legacies is vital in unpacking ongoing romantic struggles faced by diverse individuals.
Love Beyond the Framework of Romance
The discourse surrounding love is distinguished from the limitations of romance, highlighting the innate capacity for compassion and connection that exists within all individuals. Rejecting the concept that love must fit within a romantic mold allows for a more inclusive understanding of human relationships. This inclusive vision emphasizes selflessness and kindness as core components of love, while critiquing societal standards that dictate who is deemed lovable. Recognizing that everyone is deserving of love helps to challenge and reshape narratives around desirability.
Abby and Patrick welcome Sabrina Strings, professor and North Hall Chair of Black Studies at UC Santa Barbara, to talk about her new book, The End of Love: Racism, Sexism, and the Death of Romance. The book is both a deep dive into the genealogy of western notions of "romance" - from medieval courtly love to Victorian mother/whore complexes - and a searing critique of contemporary ideologies of love, normative gender roles, practices of dating, and more. Strings takes Abby and Patrick on a journey through how a seemingly abstract "Romantic Ideal" is in fact dependent on histories of racialization, abjection, and a formulation of the bodies of black women as "the commons." Tracing the legacies of these histories to the present, they examine how love, transgressive and otherwise, gets represented in media from Sex and the City and Friends to reality TV shows from Love is Blind to the (undersung) Tool Academy. Must the legacy of Romantic love as a mechanism for perpetuating the social reproduction of inequality and subordination continue to weigh on our relationships today - or are there other possibilities? Plus: a critical theory of the fuckboy!
Have you noticed that Freud is back? Got questions about psychoanalysis? Or maybe you’ve traversed the fantasy and lived to tell the tale? Leave us a voicemail! (646) 450-0847
A podcast about psychoanalysis, politics, pop culture, and the ways we suffer now. New episodes on Saturdays. Follow us on social media: