In this conversation, Frank Bruni, a New York Times columnist and bestselling author, shares insights on the turbulent intersection of culture and politics. He and Kevin D. Williamson explore the haunting themes of The Exorcist and how they resonate with today's political grievances. They discuss the toxic obsession with resentment in American discourse, the challenges posed by economic divides, and the rise of victimization narratives. Bruni also critiques the disconnect within elite institutions and reflects on empathy's role in fostering connections in a fragmented society.
The podcast highlights a growing ambiguity in political affiliations, reflecting shifts in traditional ideological landscapes and voices for many individuals.
A deep appreciation for 'The Exorcist' is discussed, emphasizing its intricate storytelling and how its cultural context has evolved over time.
The concept of an 'Age of Grievance' illustrates how pervasive resentment shapes American political sentiments and social cohesion, fueled by social media comparisons.
Deep dives
Reflections on Political Affiliations
There is a growing ambiguity regarding political affiliations and ideological alignments in today's discourse. The speaker expresses uncertainty about who is on the 'right' or 'left,' reflecting a shift in political landscapes. This sentiment is further illustrated through past influences, such as once enjoying writing from magazines that are now perceived as unrecognizable from their original form. The conversation emphasizes the difficulty many face in connecting with political voices that once resonated with them.
Appreciation for Craft in Cinema
The speaker discusses a deep appreciation for the craft of the film 'The Exorcist,' highlighting its intricate storytelling and impressive performances. Notably, the elements that resonate most include themes of illness and parental vulnerability, which evoke a personal connection. An anecdote about running up the film's iconic steps showcases a blend of nostalgia and personal experience tied to the movie's history. The discussion conveys an admiration for classic cinema, alongside a recognition of how its context has changed over the years.
The Age of Grievance Explored
The concept of an 'Age of Grievance' emerges as a significant topic, focusing on how grievances shape political sentiments across ideologies. It examines how individuals perceive themselves as uniquely wronged, stemming from both legitimate and delusional beliefs. This pervasive sense of grievance has carved out a disturbing narrative within American society, leading to divisiveness and calls for vengeance against perceived oppressors. The exploration of this theme highlights its implications on social cohesion and common understanding.
Social Media's Role in Resentment
The conversation reveals the impact of social media as an 'engine of envy,' exacerbating feelings of resentment among individuals. The ease of sharing lifestyle luxuries creates an unending comparison among peers, fostering a culture of grievance. This shift not only highlights economic disparities but also sheds light on how social media cultivates discontent. The implications of this phenomenon change how individuals perceive their own lives, often focusing on what they lack rather than expressing gratitude for what they possess.
Meritocracy and Socioeconomic Divide
A discussion around meritocracy examines how societal perceptions of merit often revolve around educational pedigree and socioeconomic background. The speaker reinforces the narrative that traditional measures of success, based on prestigious education, may overlook other valuable life experiences. This focus creates a divide, casting judgment on individuals based on their academic achievements rather than their character or practical skills. Ultimately, the conversation calls for a broader understanding of merit that recognizes diverse paths to success.
Earlier this week, Jonah took a visit to a sacred temple in India, where he engaged in several hours of deep meditation that eventually resulted in his ascension to nirvana. Those who have reached the highest plane of enlightenment tend to reject earthly concerns like podcasts, so the helm of The Remnant has been passed to a former theater critic operating under the alias of Kevin D. Williamson.
Kevin is joined by Frank Bruni of the New York Times, primarily to discuss The Exorcist, which happens to have a lot of crossover with the current state of American politics. The two dig in to the absence of gratitude and obsession with grievances plaguing political discourse, the roots of mounting resentment between economic classes, and the woes of commercial air travel.
The Remnant is a production of The Dispatch, a digital media company covering politics, policy, and culture from a non-partisan, conservative perspective. To access all of The Dispatch’s offerings—including Jonah’s G-File newsletter, weekly livestreams, and other members-only content—click here.