99 | What is Dialectics? Part VI: From Explanation to Emancipation: Roy Bhaskar’s Critical Realism
Oct 14, 2024
auto_awesome
Delve into Roy Bhaskar's critical realism, tackling the chasm between fact and value in the human sciences. Discover how knowledge can empower self-emancipation, especially amidst middle-class complacency. The conversation covers Spinoza’s insights on emotion and activism, exploring the interplay of trust and joy. The complexities of socialist movements are scrutinized, emphasizing the importance of working-class focus. Engaging philosophical discussions highlight the role of theory in fostering understanding and collective action.
01:01:35
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
Roy Bhaskar's critical realism emphasizes the importance of uncovering the deeper societal mechanisms over mere surface-level experiences in understanding social phenomena.
Scientific knowledge plays a pivotal role in self-emancipation by challenging false beliefs and empowering individuals to reshape their understanding of societal structures.
Understanding the difference between oppressive and empowering social determinants is crucial for fostering informed choices and transformative actions in the quest for emancipation.
Deep dives
Understanding Bashkar's Critical Realism
Critical realism, as proposed by Roy Bashkar, is a philosophical approach that emphasizes the importance of understanding the underlying mechanisms that generate observable social phenomena. Bashkar posits that traditional empiricist views fall short by merely acknowledging surface-level experiences without delving into the deeper structures that produce such phenomena. For example, while it may seem like an individual choice determines housing segregation, critical realism pushes us to investigate broader societal dynamics, such as economic incentives and historical patterns of discrimination. This perspective thus seeks to reveal the complex interconnections within social realities, advocating for a more nuanced understanding of the factors that shape human behavior and social structures.
The Role of Explanation in Emancipation
Bashkar argues that scientific explanation plays a crucial role in human emancipation by uncovering false beliefs that arise from distorted perceptions of society. He suggests that if science can demonstrate that certain beliefs about social structures are false, it provides a basis for individuals to strive for their modification or removal. The process extends to collectively recognizing and addressing the generative mechanisms that perpetuate these false beliefs, thereby enabling individuals to navigate and reshape their reality. Bashkar insists that this journey from recognizing false consciousness to seeking emancipation requires not just belief in the truth, but also the knowledge of how to dismantle oppressive structures.
The Concept of Emancipation
For Bashkar, emancipation is not simply about becoming free from all forms of determination but rather transitioning to empowering sources of determination that align with human needs and desires. This shift involves recognizing the difference between unwanted oppressive forces and those that promote self-development and well-being. Bashkar emphasizes that understanding the generative mechanisms behind social phenomena is essential for making informed decisions about how to create desired social structures and empower individuals. He presents emancipation as a transformative process requiring informed choice, active engagement, and a recognition of the complexity of social systems.
Realism and Knowledge as Empowerment
Bashkar's critical realism maintains that knowledge acquisition is fundamentally empowering, as it equips individuals with the necessary tools to understand and interact with their societal structures more effectively. He highlights that knowledge is not inherently political, but rather serves to uncover realities that can inform collective action and societal change. By presenting a realistic ontology of social phenomena, Bashkar guides individuals and movements to critically engage with their environment and push for transformative actions rooted in accurate comprehension. This approach prioritizes the development of a critical awareness that can lead to meaningful social reform based on an understanding of the interplay between structures, agency, and beliefs.
The Limits of Scientific Prediction
Bashkar distinguishes between explanation and prediction within the realm of human sciences, asserting that while scientific inquiry can reveal mechanisms that lead to social phenomena, it does not inherently allow for accurate predictions of social change. This limitation speaks to the complexity of social interactions and the myriad of factors influencing human behavior, which can often lead to non-linear and unpredictable outcomes. He argues that focusing solely on predictive models can misguide action and obscure the deeper mechanisms at play in society. Instead, he advocates for a robust explanation of the social world that identifies generative structures, allowing for informed action rather than merely relying on predictive assertions.
In this episode, we discuss the philosopher of science Roy Bhaskar and his essays in Reclaiming Reality. We discuss whether it is possible for the human sciences to overcome the fact/value distinction, what role knowledge has in self-emancipation, and what to do about middle-class surburbanites who would rather watch the world burn than take a hit on their property values. Some highlights include the pod disagreeing on Althusser, Spinoza’s joy saving the day, and settling accounts with the role of the activist-intellectual in contemporary times.
patreon.com/leftofphilosophy
References:
Roy Bhaskar, Reclaiming Reality: A Critical Introduction to Contemporary Philosophy (New York: Routledge, 2011).
Music:
“Vintage Memories” by Schematist | schematist.bandcamp.com
“My Space” by Overu | https://get.slip.stream/KqmvAN
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode