In a compelling discussion, historian Daniel Immerwahr delves into America’s hidden history of imperialism, exposing how it intertwined with ideals of democracy and freedom. He shares how guano, a seemingly unremarkable resource, fueled America's overseas ambitions. Immerwahr also highlights the complex debates about American identity in light of territorial expansion, and he explores the often-overlooked realities of labor exploitation during the 19th century. The conversation sheds light on the lasting impacts of this imperial past on contemporary issues of citizenship and identity.
American imperialism has deeply influenced perceptions of citizenship, especially in territories like Puerto Rico and the Philippines where residents lack full rights.
The guano industry exemplifies the exploitative nature of U.S. expansionism, highlighting brutal labor practices and the legal complexities surrounding overseas governance.
Deep dives
The Misrepresentation of America's Geographic Identity
The traditional understanding of the geographical boundaries of the United States is limited and misleading, often depicted as a contiguous territory that excludes its historical possessions and colonies. Most educational representations of the nation neglect to consider territories like Puerto Rico and the Philippines, leaving many unaware that the U.S. used to hold a more expansive empire. This truncated view of history significantly shapes American identity and perceptions of citizenship, as many citizens do not realize that numerous individuals living in these territories are U.S. nationals but not citizens. Consequently, the implications of this identity gap can be traced back to assumptions about national sovereignty and belonging, often manifested in misinformed public discourse, such as comments made about Puerto Rico's status after Hurricane Maria.
Guano Mining: A Dark Chapter in U.S. Imperialism
The guano industry, which thrived in the 19th century due to the increasing demand for fertilizer, serves as a grim example of America's imperial ambitions and the exploitation that accompanied them. Guano mining was not only dangerous but also involved the manipulation of African American workers who were lured by promises of a better life, only to find themselves in brutal conditions on remote islands. The harsh treatment and poor labor conditions led to mutinies, notably on Navassa Island, where workers killed several overseers in an act of revolt against the oppressive labor regime. This uprising not only attracted media attention but also led to significant legal battles that raised questions about the applicability of U.S. law in overseas territories, laying the groundwork for the country’s colonial governance.
The Shift Towards U.S. Imperialism in the Late 19th Century
The late 19th century marked a transition in American identity and policy, as the nation embraced imperialism following the Spanish-American War. Following the conflict, the U.S. acquired territories such as Guam, Puerto Rico, and the Philippines, provoking a national debate over its role as an empire. This expansion led to a shift in cartography, resulting in the creation of new maps that included these territories, which fundamentally altered the perception of what constituted America. The rhetoric around this period was laden with a paternalistic notion of civilizing non-white populations, reminiscent of British justifications for their own imperial pursuits, while simultaneously igniting a fierce anti-imperialist conversation within the U.S.
The Lasting Consequences of U.S. Colonial Practices
The legacy of American imperialism continues to complicate the discourse surrounding citizenship and legal rights within U.S. territories today, exemplified by the Insular Cases which determined that constitutional rights do not extend to these areas. This has resulted in millions of people, such as those in Puerto Rico and American Samoa, living under a legal framework that allows for taxation without representation and a lack of full citizenship rights. The consequences of this systemic inequality are evident in contemporary events, where residents of these territories often feel the impacts of policies determined by Washington without their input. Therefore, engaging with this history is crucial for understanding the ongoing implications of U.S. sovereignty and legitimacy, as well as the sentiments of those living in the U.S. territories.
The complete story of American imperialism is missing from our history books. On this week’s On the Media, how the United States worked to capture territory and expand power, while preaching democracy and freedom.
[01:00] Host Brooke Gladstone sits down with historian Daniel Immerwahr, on the hidden history of the United States empire. For Americans, empire often means economic and military power abroad, or CIA coups in Central America–not British-style imperialism. But the American empire was — and in some ways continues to be — a lot closer than most people realize. Immerwahr explains the role of guano — bird poop — in launching America's overseas empire, and the legal, political and social clashes that ensued.
[17:57] Host Brooke Gladstone continues her conversation with historian Daniel Immerwahr, exploring why, at the dawn of the last century, the arguments over imperialism didn’t end with poets like Rudyard Kipling and writers like Mark Twain. How should the adolescent U.S., big-headed about its democratic values, grapple with capturing territory? Immerwahr explains how this vital debate blazed across America’s consciousness like a comet, then vanished just as quickly.
[34:47] Host Brooke Gladstone and historian Daniel Immerwahr conclude their conversation, discussing how, after World War II, global anti-colonial sentiment (combined with less dependence on natural resources) led to a shrinking of America's physical empire. But the American empire didn't disappear — it merely changed form.
On the Media is supported by listeners like you. Support OTM by donating today (https://pledge.wnyc.org/support/otm). Follow our show on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook @onthemedia, and share your thoughts with us by emailing onthemedia@wnyc.org.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode