The McShay Show
NFL Draft Recap: Favorite Picks and Full Class Breakdowns for All 32 Teams
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
- The Ravens demonstrated a strategic approach by selecting versatile players like Malachi Starks to address pressing defensive needs.
- The Bengals focused on enhancing their defense, acquiring talent like edge rusher Shamar Stewart to improve their pass rush.
- The Browns executed a bold strategy, trading back to secure valuable assets while bolstering their defense and offense with key picks.
- The Steelers prioritized roster depth in the draft, selecting players such as Derek Harmon to reinforce both their offense and defense.
- The Cowboys made impactful defensive selections and balanced their draft strategy despite uncertainties regarding potential player losses to free agency.
Deep dives
Overview of NFL Draft Strategies
The episode outlines vital strategies employed by various NFL teams during the draft. Teams prioritized filling specific positional needs while balancing the potential value of players available at different draft spots. Organizations like the Ravens showcased patience by leveraging their draft position to maximize talent acquisition without rushing their picks. Additionally, several teams emphasized the importance of finding versatile players that could fill multiple roles on their rosters, a crucial strategy for today's fast-paced NFL.
Analysis of the Baltimore Ravens' Draft
The Baltimore Ravens made notable moves during the draft, emphasizing their strategy of waiting for the right players to fall to their position. They selected Malachi Starks, a safety from Georgia, whose versatility addresses their defensive needs after a rough previous season. The team's second round pick, Mike Green, came with some off-field concerns but has the potential to be an impact player upon joining the Ravens' defensive line. The overall draft strategy involved focusing on immediate contributors while maintaining a long-term vision with their selections.
Cincinnati Bengals' Focus on Defense
The Cincinnati Bengals approached the draft with a clear focus on enhancing their defensive capabilities. Their first round pick was Shamar Stewart, a highly talented edge rusher who brings upside but requires development. The Bengals recognized their need to strengthen their defense, and thus secured three of their first four picks on that side of the ball. By enhancing their pass rush and run defense, the Bengals aim to solidify their standing in the competitive AFC.
Cleveland Browns' Strategic Moves
The Cleveland Browns executed a bold draft strategy that included trading back to gain further assets for the future. They selected Mason Graham, a defensive tackle projected by many as a top-five player, which signals their intent to build a more aggressive and dominant defensive line alongside Miles Garrett. The Browns also focused on bolstering their offense with skill positions, selecting running backs and a linebacker to round out their class. This draft reflects a deeper emphasis on long-term organizational health rather than immediate gratification.
Assessing the Pittsburgh Steelers' Draft
The Pittsburgh Steelers had a productive draft, making selections that enhanced their roster depth and future potential. Their first pick, Derek Harmon, aligns with their traditional focus on toughness and physicality in the trenches. Additionally, with selections like Caleb Johnson and Jack Sawyer, the Steelers addressed both their offensive needs and the need for defensive reinforcements. The overall strategy appears centered on bolstering their defense while also ensuring they bring in talent at critical skill positions.
Reflection on the Dallas Cowboys' Picks
The Dallas Cowboys made their mark with a solid draft, acquiring Tyler Booker in the first round despite some reservations about his fit. Following that, they made several impactful selections on defense, including Donovan Azaraku and Trey Amos, both expected to strengthen the Cowboys' defensive front. The value they found in their later picks allowed them to balance their overall needs while still addressing the potential loss of key players to free agency. This draft positions the Cowboys favorably heading into next season with depth and talent.
New York Giants' Draft Success
The New York Giants had a strong draft, securing key players such as Jalen Carter and securing future needs at quarterback with Jackson Dart. Their strategy shows a focus on building a competitive team while acknowledging the importance of overseeing aging players at key positions. The draft is marked by a series of selections that reflect the organization's vision of pairing talented youth with experienced veterans, providing a bright outlook for the Giants. Critics recognized the potential long-term benefits of this draft, positioning New York for future success.
Los Angeles Rams' Value Selections
The Rams leveraged their draft capital to secure a variety of players who can immediately contribute while also planning for the future. Their selections reflect a keen understanding of the team's needs, particularly on the defensive side with the addition of Josiah Stewart. The Rams' ability to identify players who fit their system showcases their long-standing organization philosophy under Les Snead. Overall, their draft results further solidify their status as a competitive force in the league.
Seattle Seahawks' Comprehensive Strategy
The Seattle Seahawks executed a comprehensive strategy during the draft by acquiring a mix of immediate-impact players and developmental prospects. With Mikel Williams and Jalen Milrow, they addressed both their pass rush and quarterback depth, showcasing their focus on building a young foundation. The later picks, including Riley Mills and Torrey Horton, added further depth and explosiveness, particularly to their offensive skill sets. This draft aligns with the Seahawks' long-term vision of enhancing their competitive edge in the league.
Welcome back to The McShay Show! The guys go team by team to evaluate every class in the 2025 NFL draft. They give their favorite picks, team fits, and everything in between.
(0:00) Welcome to The McShay Show!
(2:25) Evaluating EVERY Team's Draft
(2:35) AFC North: Baltimore Ravens
(9:55) AFC North: Cincinnati Bengals
(14:20) AFC North: Cleveland Browns
(23:24) AFC North: Pittsburgh Steelers
(27:50) AFC South: Houston Texans
(32:00) AFC South: Indianapolis Colts
(35:10) AFC South: Jacksonville Jaguars
(39:35) AFC South: Tennessee Titans
(42:23) AFC East: Buffalo Bills
(46:55) AFC East: Miami Dolphins
(50:45) AFC East: New England Patriots
(54:45) AFC East: New York Jets
(1:00:00) AFC West: Denver Broncos
(1:03:45) AFC West: Kansas City Chiefs
(1:07:10) AFC West: Las Vegas Raiders
(1:10:30) AFC West: Los Angeles Chargers
(1:14:15) NFC North: Chicago Bears
(1:18:45) NFC North: Detroit Lions
(1:22:45) NFC North: Green Bay Packers
(1:26:35) NFC North: Minnesota Vikings
(1:29:50) NFC South: Atlanta Falcons
(1:37:00) NFC South: Carolina Panthers
(1:40:50) NFC South: New Orleans Saints
(1:44:00) NFC South: Tampa Bay Buccaneers
(1:47:05) NFC East: Dallas Cowboys
(1:49:57) NFC East: New York Giants
(1:53:57) NFC East: Philadelphia Eagles
(1:59:30) NFC East: Washington Commanders
(2:01:40) NFC West: Arizona Cardinals
(2:04:35) NFC West: Los Angeles Rams
(2:08:06) NFC West: San Francisco 49ers
(2:12:13) NFC West: Seattle Seahawks
The Ringer is committed to responsible gaming. Please visit www.rg-help.com to learn more about the resources and helplines available.
Host: Todd McShay
Guest: Steve Muench
Producers: Tucker Tashjian, Mark Panik, Conor Nevins, and Daniel Comer
Social: Eduardo Ocampo
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
