

HoP 476 What He Should Have Said: the Early Cartesians
Sep 21, 2025
Explore how early Cartesians like Cordemoy and de La Forge both defended and challenged Descartes' ideas. Discover occasionalism, where God is seen as the primary cause, and its implications on mind-body interaction. Delve into the bold claims of atomism, advocating for the existence of void. Uncover how Cartesian thought spread across Europe, sparking academic battles and adaptations aligned with religious views. Lastly, engage with reflections on the social reach of Cartesianism, including its gender implications.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
God Versus Created Causes
- Early Cartesians debated whether God alone causes motion or whether created causes act alongside God.
- This debate linked metaphysical causation to theological disputes about grace and human responsibility.
Gousset’s Reported Conversation With La Forge
- Jacques Gousset reported Louis de La Forge saying God produces all bodily and mental actions during a 1658 conversation.
- La Forge reportedly refused theological objections by claiming he was not a theologian.
Occasionalism Defined And Its Early Roots
- Occasionalism holds that created events are merely occasions for God to produce effects.
- Early Cartesians like La Forge and Caudemois advanced occasionalism before Malebranche popularized it.