Environmental differences, particularly access to nutritious native crops and domesticable animals, played a crucial role in determining the pace and trajectory of civilization, with the Fertile Crescent in Western Eurasia having a superior array of useful plants and animals, resulting in the rise of stratified societies and a head start in the development of guns, germs, and steel compared to other societies.
Eurasian societies had a significant advantage due to their exposure to domesticated animals and the diseases that evolved from them, resulting in genetic resistance to diseases such as smallpox, flu, and malaria, which decimated non-Eurasian populations upon contact with European explorers, significantly impacting the course of history.
Deep dives
Environmental differences and the rise of civilization
Jared Diamond's book 'Guns, Germs, and Steel' explores the reasons behind the divergent paths of development on different continents. He argues that environmental differences, particularly in terms of access to nutritious native crops and domesticable animals, played a crucial role in determining the pace and trajectory of civilization. Specifically, the Fertile Crescent in Western Eurasia possessed a superior array of useful plants and animals, enabling the development of settled agriculture, population growth, and the rise of stratified societies with specialized craft and warrior classes. This environmental advantage eventually translated into eurasians having a head start in the development of guns, germs, and steel compared to other societies.
The impact of disease and germs
One significant advantage of Eurasian societies was their exposure to domesticated animals and the diseases that evolved from them. Eurasians developed genetic resistance to diseases such as smallpox, flu, tuberculosis, and malaria, which were devastating to non-Eurasian societies. When Europeans arrived in the Americas, it was the introduction of Eurasian germs, rather than their guns and steel, that decimated Native American populations. Up to 95% of the original indigenous population died from exposure to Eurasian diseases, significantly affecting the course of history.
Limitations of Diamond's argument
While Jared Diamond's analysis provides valuable insights into the role of environmental factors in shaping human history, there are limitations to his argument. One criticism is his focus on the broad concepts of Eurasia and Africa, overlooking the significant variations within those regions. Additionally, Diamond does not fully address the question of why Northwest Europe, despite its historical backwater status, ultimately outpaced other Eurasian societies in terms of technological, economic, and political advancements. To delve deeper into this question, further exploration of works by other authors, such as David Landes' 'The Wealth and Poverty of Nations,' may be necessary.
Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies was published by Jared Diamond in 1997. It won the Pulitzer Prize in 1998, along with several other awards. The fundamental question that Diamond seeks to answer through this book is, why did history unfold so differently on different continents such that Eurasian societies became so disproportionately influential in creating the modern world?