Why Stoicism Doesn’t Work Without God | Tad Brennan on Stoic Ethics
Apr 26, 2025
auto_awesome
Tad Brennan, a Cornell professor specializing in ancient philosophy and Stoicism, dives deep into the relationship between Stoic ethics and theology. He argues that true Stoic ethics requires a belief in God, emphasizing the intricacies of Stoic philosophy and the importance of virtue in achieving happiness. The discussion also contrasts Stoicism with Aristotelian ethics, exploring how divine rationality impacts our understanding of ethics. Brennan highlights the role of moral exemplars and critiques practical ethics within Stoicism, shedding light on the complexities of ethical reasoning.
Stoicism fundamentally requires a belief in God, specifically Zeus, to provide a theological foundation for its ethical principles.
The essence of Stoic virtue lies in the understanding that true happiness is achieved through moral choices responding to life's indifferent circumstances.
Navigating indifferent aspects of life, like wealth and health, is crucial to Stoic ethics, defining one's ethical character through skillful engagement.
Deep dives
Theological Foundations of Stoicism
Stoicism is rooted in a belief in God, specifically Zeus, making secular interpretations ineffective. The essence of Stoic ethics is interconnected with its theology, as human nature is regarded as a fraction of divine nature. This divine perspective shapes Stoic ethics, emphasizing that virtue alone constitutes true happiness. Without acknowledging a divine framework, the fundamental principles of Stoicism become hollow, underscoring the need for a theological foundation in understanding Stoicism.
Understanding Virtue in Stoicism
In Stoicism, virtue is defined as the knowledge that constitutes a good human being, centered on understanding what is genuinely valuable. The Stoics claim that only virtue is inherently good and only vice is inherently bad, while everything else is indifferent, meaning it does not contribute to one's happiness or unhappiness. This principle emphasizes that a Stoic's true success hinges on how they respond to life's indifferent circumstances rather than on the circumstances themselves. Notably, part of being virtuous involves recognizing how to navigate this world of indifference effectively, thus cultivating a profound knowledge of human experiences.
The Role of Indifference in Stoic Ethics
Indifferent phenomena, such as health, wealth, and status, play a crucial role in Stoic ethics, as they do not influence happiness but require skillful management. The knowledge of dealing with the indifferent aspects of life constitutes a significant part of Stoic virtue. This skillful navigation of indifference is what defines a virtuous person, akin to a player mastering the rules of a game. Therefore, while indifference does not contribute to happiness, how one engages with these indifferent factors reflects their ethical character.
Nature and the Stoic Way of Life
Living in accordance with nature involves understanding the natural world as a manifestation of divine order, providing insight into virtue. Nature reveals both regularities and anomalies, with Stoics interpreting these observations as reflections of Zeus's will. Consequently, actions align with natural order, such as nurturing offspring, which is deemed instinctive and virtuous. This perspective suggests that engaging with nature is fundamentally intertwined with Stoic ethics, further reinforcing the idea that Stoicism cannot be divorced from its theological roots.
Stoicism's Impact on Personal Decision-Making
A Stoic's daily decisions are ideally guided by an integration of virtue, indifferent selection, and natural alignment, wherein each aspect converges to inform moral action. However, the challenge arises from the Stoic belief that true virtue is rarely attained, complicating the decision-making process. Instead, they focus on the choices surrounding indifference, positioning it as the primary guide in their deliberation. This framework suggests that real engagement with ethical dilemmas comes from understanding how to select indifference wisely, emphasizing a daily practice of Stoicism grounded in rational choices rather than aspirational virtue alone.
An interview with Cornell's Tad Brennan on Stoic ethics & religion
This channel is funded directly by people passionate about the Great Books. Help me keep making more episodes with a paid subscription: johnathanbi.com
