"Between the Covers" Live: Dionne Brand and Adania Shibli
Oct 2, 2024
auto_awesome
In this engaging discussion, renowned writer Dionne Brand, celebrated for her exploration of colonial narratives, teams up with Adania Shibli, who examines themes of home and empire impact. They delve into reimagining belonging beyond nation-states, confronting colonial erasures of everyday life. The conversation also critiques the failures of liberal democracy, especially in the context of Israeli-Palestinian tensions. Brand and Shibli highlight the transformative power of writing, calling for collective narratives that foster liberation and challenge oppressive legacies.
Dionne Brand and Adania Shibli discuss 'home' as a complex, ethical concept shaped by historical violence rather than a fixed location.
The authors emphasize the importance of reimagining narratives to include multifaceted lived experiences that resist imperialistic interpretations.
Deep dives
The Concept of Home in Literature
The discussion emphasizes the complex nature of 'home' as portrayed in literary works, particularly in the novels of Adania Shibley and Dion Brand. Shibley reflects on her experiences of restlessness, noting that for her, Palestine represents an ethical relationship rather than a traditional homeland. This perspective challenges conventional notions of safety associated with home, leaning towards an understanding of home as a temporary state rather than a fixed location. Brand further complicates this by arguing that the term 'home' is burdened with historical and social implications that often perpetuate violence, thus advocating for a more nuanced and open-ended interpretation of the concept.
Maps, Narratives, and Colonial Erasure
The conversation explores the relationship between maps and narratives, highlighting how maps can serve as tools of both orientation and erasure. Shibley shares her character's bewilderment in navigating spaces where towns have disappeared, signifying the broader theme of disorientation caused by colonial histories. Brand articulates the importance of narrative as a means to recount lived experiences that defy linear storytelling shaped by colonialist agendas. Both writers advocate for reimagining narratives to include multifaceted lived realities that resist imperialistic interpretations.
Resistance to Grand Narratives
A central theme in their dialogue is the rejection of grand narratives that attempt to encapsulate complex identities and histories. Shibley emphasizes that proposing a grand narrative about Palestine can lead to oversimplifications and misrepresentations of the lived realities of its people. Instead, she suggests embracing smaller narratives that reflect the multiplicity of experiences, particularly those that challenge the status quo of narratives defined by oppression. Brand also recognizes the limitations of traditional storytelling, advocating for narratives that promote liberation rather than conforming to existing structures of power.
The Role of Writing in Times of Crisis
In light of recent global events, both authors articulate the necessity of writing as a form of resistance to dehumanization and despair. They reflect on how writing serves as a means to navigate the complexities of identity, ethics, and the urgency of political realities. Shibley recounts her belief that writing must reflect authentic experiences while acting as an act of survival, preventing one from becoming desensitized or complicit in ongoing violence. Ultimately, their conversation underscores the empowering potential of artistic expression in fostering connections and understanding amidst societal turmoil.
For this live taping of the literary podcast Between the Covers—recorded at Jewish Currents’s daylong event on September 15th and presented in partnership with On the Nose—host David Naimon convened a conversation with renowned writers Dionne Brand and Adania Shibli about contesting colonial narratives. Rooted in their long-standing literary practice and in the demands of this moment of genocide, they discuss the vexed meanings of home, how to recover the everydayness of life erased by empire, and what it means to imagine togetherness beyond the nation-state.
This episode was produced by David Naimon, with music by Alicia Jo Rabins. Thanks also to Jesse Brenneman for additional editing and to Nathan Salsburg for the use of his song “VIII (All That Were Calculated Have Passed).