Caterina Fugazzola, "Words Like Water: Queer Mobilization and Social Change in China" (Temple UP, 2023)
Sep 26, 2024
auto_awesome
Caterina Fugazzola, an expert on queer mobilization in China, discusses her book that highlights strategies for social change post-decriminalization of same-sex behavior. She contrasts local approaches with Western tactics, emphasizing community narratives over confrontation. Fugazzola shares her academic journey and the metaphor of 'Words Like Water' to illustrate adaptability in activism. Personal stories reveal the resilience of China's queer community, navigating cultural expectations and a complex relationship with the government, all while fostering hope for the future.
The tongzhi movement in China employs non-confrontational strategies, focusing on community narratives to foster social change under authoritarian constraints.
The evolution of LGBT NGOs in China illustrates the challenges and resilience of queer activism, adapting to political restrictions while promoting acceptance.
Deep dives
Non-Confrontational Strategies in Chinese Queer Activism
Queer movements in China often adopt non-confrontational strategies to navigate the socio-political context, especially in light of government pushback against Western-style activism. These strategies focus on community and family-oriented narratives, allowing queer activists to engage in social change without the backlash that comes from direct confrontations, such as protests. By prioritizing relationships and shared cultural values, queer organizers have managed to create spaces for dialogue and acceptance, leading to a more integrated approach to activism. This tactical flexibility enables groups to operate within the constraints of the political environment while promoting their goals effectively.
The Landscape of LGBT NGOs in China
The landscape of LGBT NGOs in China has evolved significantly since the late 1990s when same-sex behavior was decriminalized and homosexuality was removed from the list of mental disorders. Numerous organizations emerged during the early 2000s, focusing on various domains, from family support to legal advocacy, resulting in the establishment of physical community spaces. However, many of these groups must navigate a complex political landscape, balancing their visibility goals and the avoidance of overt confrontational tactics, which often limits their effectiveness. Understanding these nuances showcases the adaptability and resilience of China’s queer communities in the face of state scrutiny and limitations.
Cultural Nuances in Coming Out Narratives
The notion of 'coming out' in China differs fundamentally from Western interpretations, as queer activists emphasize a concept referred to as 'coming home.' This strategy avoids direct confrontation with family by introducing partners in a non-explicit manner, fostering acceptance over time without labeling the relationship. PFLAG China has adapted this approach, encouraging narratives from parents of queer children, which allows them to share emotional journeys towards acceptance while redefining familial bonds. Consequently, this creates a unique space for dialogue that effectively integrates queerness into traditional family dynamics, illustrating how cultural context shapes identity and activism.
The Impact of Political Changes on LGBT Organizations
Recent political shifts have severely impacted the operations and visibility of LGBT organizations in China, leading to increased challenges for activists. Many NGOs have faced closure or restrictions, resulting in leaders and activists seeking refuge abroad to continue their work. Despite these setbacks, there remains a spirit of resilience within the community, with many groups strategically recalibrating their approaches, focusing on smaller and more discreet forms of engagement. The ongoing adaptation of queer activism reflects the creativity and resourcefulness of these organizations, which continue to find ways to support one another and maintain their presence, even in a more challenging environment.
After China officially “decriminalized” same-sex behavior in 1997, both the visibility and public acceptance of tongzhi, an inclusive identity term that refers to nonheterosexual and gender nonconforming identities in the People’s Republic of China, has improved. However, for all the positive change, there are few opportunities for political and civil rights advocacy under Xi Jinping’s authoritarian rule.
Words Like Water: Queer Mobilization and Social Change in China(Temple UP, 2023) explores the nonconfrontational strategies the tongzhi movement uses in contemporary China. Caterina Fugazzola analyzes tongzhi organizers’ conceptualizations of, and approaches to, social change, explaining how they avoid the backlash that meets Western tactics, such as protests, confrontation, and language about individual freedoms. In contrast, the groups’ intentional use of community and family-oriented narratives, discourses, and understandings of sexual identity are more effective, especially in situations where direct political engagement is not possible.
Providing on-the-ground stories that examine the social, cultural, and political constraints and opportunities, Words like Water emphasizes the value of discursive flexibility that allows activists to adapt to changing social and political conditions.
Caterina Fugazzola is Assistant Senior Instructional Professor of Global Studies at the University of Chicago.
Qing Shen is a PhD candidate in anthropology at Uppsala University, Sweden.