Joe Coscarelli, a culture reporter for The New York Times, dives deep into the complex intersection of hip-hop and crime, focusing on the high-profile trial of rapper Young Thug. He discusses how the RICO Act is being used against hip-hop artists and the implications this has for the culture. The conversation explores how lyrics can be weaponized as evidence, questioning the authenticity of rap and its ties to street life. Coscarelli also examines how plea deals influence the hierarchy within rap collectives, shedding light on the blurry lines between artistry and criminality.
Young Thug's success as a rapper is being called into question as he stands trial alongside members of YSL, accused of operating as a criminal street gang
The outcome of the trial could challenge the perception and credibility of other rappers' claims about their backgrounds and lifestyles
Deep dives
The Rise of Young Thug in the Music Industry
Young Thug, born Jeffrey Williams, emerged as a rap innovator from Atlanta. He pushed boundaries in terms of his style, dress, and sound, experimenting with abstract lyrics and unique vocal delivery. Despite initial doubts, Young Thug became a popular musician and an influential figure in the rap genre. He formed the collective YSL and helped launch the careers of other successful rappers. As he gained mainstream success, he also faced legal troubles, including arrests for drug and gun charges. However, these issues did not hinder his music career, and he continued to rise in popularity, crossing over into the mainstream and working with pop singers. Young Thug's success as a rapper is now being called into question as he stands trial alongside members of YSL, accused of operating as a criminal street gang involved in crimes such as murder, armed robbery, and drug dealing. The prosecution argues that he used his music to promote and strengthen the reputation of the gang. The defense maintains that Young Thug's persona and lyrics are part of an artistic expression and that he is being unfairly targeted as a successful rapper.
The Trial and Prosecution's Case Against Young Thug
The trial against Young Thug and members of YSL began in Atlanta. The prosecution aims to prove that YSL operated as a criminal street gang, with Young Thug as its leader. They present evidence such as clothing, tattoos, social media posts, and emojis as signs of gang affiliation. The prosecution also links YSL to various crimes, including a 2015 murder that allegedly triggered a gang war in Atlanta, resulting in over 50 retaliatory shootings. Two defendants in the trial are charged with the execution of the 2015 murder, while Young Thug is accused of organizing and approving the crime. The prosecution points to Young Thug's lyrics, including references to a Chevy Tahoe, matching the vehicle involved in the murder, as evidence of his involvement. However, the defense argues that the lyrics and imagery in Young Thug's music are artistic expressions and not admissions of real-life crimes.
Implications for the Hip-Hop Community and Atlanta
The outcome of the trial could have significant implications for the hip-hop community and the city of Atlanta. Rap music often revolves around themes of authenticity and personal experiences, and if Young Thug is found guilty of leading a criminal enterprise, it could challenge the perception and credibility of other rappers' claims about their backgrounds and lifestyles. The trial also raises questions about the impact on the community, particularly in neglected neighborhoods like Cleveland Avenue. Some argue that removing successful artists like Young Thug from these areas may leave them further marginalized, while others believe it could contribute to making them safer. The trial is ongoing, and as it progresses, it will continue to shed light on the complex relationship between rap music, personal identity, and criminal accusations.
As a racketeering trial begins in Atlanta, much of the focus is on the high-profile defendant, the best-selling rapper Young Thug.
Joe Coscarelli, a culture reporter for The New York Times, explains why, in a sense, hip-hop itself is on trial.
Guest: Joe Coscarelli, a culture reporter for The New York Times.
Background reading:
A judge ruled in November that at least 17 specific sets of lines from the Atlanta artist and his collaborators could be used by prosecutors in the racketeering trial of YSL, a chart-topping hip-hop label and collective.
For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday.
Unlock full access to New York Times podcasts and explore everything from politics to pop culture. Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
