On the History and Philosophy of Light | Prof. Richard F. Hassing
Oct 9, 2024
auto_awesome
In this engaging discussion, Richard F. Hassing, a Research Associate Professor at the Catholic University of America, delves into the fascinating evolution of light. He contrasts Aristotle's holistic view of perception with Descartes' ideas on sensation, revealing deep implications for the mind-body relationship. Hassing also explains the brain's role in color perception, emphasizing light's intricacies beyond mere object properties. His exploration spans from early philosophies to Einstein's relativity, showcasing light's profound impact on our understanding of the universe.
The podcast contrasts Aristotle's belief in a holistic relationship between sensory perception and the external world with Descartes's mechanistic separation of mind and matter.
It also discusses the evolution of light theory, highlighting Einstein's revolutionary views that dismissed ether and established a constant speed of light across all reference frames.
Deep dives
The Mind-World Relation: Aristotle vs. Descartes
The podcast discusses the contrasting views of Aristotle and Descartes regarding the relationship between the mind and the material world, particularly in the context of light. Descartes separates the mind from the external world, asserting that sensory perceptions do not resemble their causes, and proposes that the mind processes sensations as colorless corpuscles. In contrast, Aristotle posits that the human soul inherently relates to the world, suggesting that our sensory experiences, such as vision, provide reliable access to reality. This difference highlights Aristotle's belief in a holistic understanding of the mind, where forms and colors are perceived in their actuality through light, unlike Descartes's notion of a divided perception within the brain.
Aristotle's Concept of Light
Aristotle's theory of light emphasizes the importance of light as the actualization of transparent objects and associates it with the nature of color. He argues that light is necessary for the visibility of color, describing it as the act of the transparent facilitating the perception of color. The podcast explains that whereas light allows us to see objects in their true colors, darkness limits our perception, demonstrating the dependency of color vision on light intensity. Aristotle's ideas provide a basis for understanding color perception and its relationship to external reality, positing that the human soul can receive and reflect the forms of things.
Descartes and the Nature of Light
Descartes offers a radically different conception of light, proposing it consists of lines of centrifugal force emitted from celestial bodies, impacting our optical nerves to generate sensations. He rejects the idea that light interacts with the material world in a way that resembles the Aristotelian tradition, instead asserting a mechanistic view of light built on geometric principles. This view leads Descartes to conclude that colors are merely representations within the mind, distinct from the actual properties of the external world. His mechanical approach ultimately detaches light from its formal causes, contrasting sharply with Aristotle's view of light as an essential aspect of the natural world.
The Demise of Ether and the Rise of Relativity
The discussion transitions to the concepts of ether and light within the framework of Einstein's theory of relativity, marking a significant departure from prior models. Earlier theories by Huygens and Newton based light on the presence of ether, which was thought to serve as a medium for light waves. However, experiments such as those by Michelson and Morley indicated no evidence of ether, culminating in Einstein's proposal to abandon it altogether. Einstein's theory revealed that the speed of light is constant across all frames of reference, altering our understanding of time and space, and establishing new principles that describe the invariance applied across the universe.
Professor Richard F. Hassing discusses the history and philosophy of light, contrasting Aristotle's and Descartes' views on light and perception, and exploring the development of light theories from Huygens to Einstein, including the rise and fall of the ether concept.
This episode includes a special hand-out which can be found here. The lecture was given on July 18th, 2024, at The Dominican House of Studies.
Prof. Dick Hassing is a Research Associate Professor in the School of Philosophy at the Catholic University of America. His work has focused on the History of physics and philosophy of nature, Early modern philosophy, and Political philosophy.
He is the author of Cartesian Psychophysics and the Whole Nature of Man: On Descartes's Passions of the Soul and Modern Turns in Mathematics and Physics.
Richard F. Hassing is a Research Associate Professor at the School of Philosophy at the Catholic University of America.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode