Explore the intriguing implications of Goodhart's Law in measuring philosophical progress. The discussion highlights the pitfalls of treating metrics as targets within Stoicism. Learn how true fulfillment stems from practicing Stoic principles rather than just knowing them. Insights from Epictetus emphasize transforming knowledge into actionable virtue for meaningful growth. Dive into the complexities of aligning metrics with genuine objectives in your journey through Stoicism.
Goodhart's Law illustrates how focusing on measures like test scores can undermine genuine learning and intellectual growth in education.
Stoicism emphasizes the importance of ethical action and character development over merely quoting philosophers or superficial knowledge of the principles.
Deep dives
Understanding Goodhart's Law
Goodhart's Law states that when a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure. This principle is illustrated through examples such as education, where students often optimize their efforts to achieve high test scores rather than genuinely learning the material. As a result, their focus shifts away from intellectual growth towards merely performing well on exams. This tendency undermines the initial purpose of education, which is to cultivate knowledge and understanding.
The Dangers of Misplaced Targets in Health
Health is frequently assessed by appearance, which can lead to individuals engaging in unhealthy behaviors to meet societal standards of how one should look. Bodybuilders and professional athletes may exemplify this issue, as their pursuit of a desired appearance can overshadow the true essence of health. Consequently, the focus on looks rather than overall well-being can result in harmful practices that contradict the very goal of maintaining health. This highlights the risks associated with equating measures with targets and losing sight of genuine health.
Applying Stoicism Without Becoming Vain
Practicing Stoicism calls for a focus on actions rather than mere intellectual understanding of philosophy. When individuals start measuring their progress in Stoicism by how much they can quote or cite philosophers, they risk losing the true essence of the philosophy. Epictetus emphasizes that true value lies in living according to Stoic principles rather than simply demonstrating knowledge of them. The ultimate goal should always be ethical action and character development, as opposed to superficial achievements in philosophical discourse.
Goodhart’s Law says: when a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure. But if that’s true, how should we measure our philosophical progress?
In this episode, Michael Tremblay wrestles with this question.