In this engaging conversation, Joseph Uscinski, a political scientist from the University of Miami and an expert on conspiratorial thinking, reveals intriguing insights about conspiracy theories in America. He discusses how feelings of betrayal can lead to conspiracy beliefs, especially among marginalized groups. Uscinski debunks the myth of an increased prevalence of conspiracies and explores their psychological roots. The episode also delves into surprising similarities in belief across the political spectrum, challenging stereotypes about liberals and conservatives.
Conspiracy theories have become increasingly prevalent in American politics, particularly post-2016, influenced by prominent figures like Donald Trump.
These theories often thrive on distrust of established institutions and are rooted in a psychological landscape of marginalization and betrayal.
Research indicates that belief in conspiracy theories is not limited to one political ideology, as both liberals and conservatives subscribe at similar rates.
Deep dives
Conspiracy Theories Shaping Modern Elections
The role of conspiracy theories in modern electoral politics has intensified significantly, particularly since Donald Trump's rise. This phenomenon began with the birther conspiracy theory in 2016, which questioned Barack Obama's citizenship. Subsequent elections have seen a continuum of conspiracy theories like Pizzagate and accusations of election rigging, culminating in the January 6 Capitol riots. Today, the political landscape is heavily influenced by right-wing conspiratorial narratives, suggesting a deepening entrenchment of such theories in American political culture.
The Characteristics of Thriving Conspiracy Theories
Successful conspiracy theories often appeal to a shared distrust towards established figures, such as government institutions or influential individuals like bankers. These theories typically emerge in social environments where skepticism exists, often targeting familiar adversaries recognized by potential believers. Additionally, the nature of conspiracy theories tends to be repetitive; many are rehashed versions of older narratives, which illustrates a demand for sensational storytelling within political discourse. This cyclical phenomenon demonstrates how established themes persist in engaging audiences, thus maintaining their relevance over time.
Understanding the Psychology of Believers
Conspiracy theories fundamentally rely on the notion of agency, often attributing extraordinary competence to conspirators while downplaying real-world complexities. Many conspiracy theorists frequently believe that powerful groups work in secret to manipulate outcomes for their own benefit, which feeds a narrative of betrayal and mistrust. Psychological mechanisms such as feelings of marginalization or betrayal contribute to this worldview, especially among communities that have long histories of distrust towards the government. Understanding these psychological dimensions is crucial in addressing the rise of conspiracy thinking in politics.
Contrasting Beliefs Across the Political Spectrum
Despite persistent assumptions that conspiracy belief is predominantly a right-wing issue, research shows that both liberals and conservatives subscribe to various conspiracy theories at similar rates. This indicates that while specific narratives may momentarily align with certain political factions, the overall inclination towards conspiratorial thinking is more evenly distributed across the political spectrum. Furthermore, the differences observed in belief often reflect contemporary political contexts rather than intrinsic ideological divides. Notably, factors such as individual experience and exposure to misinformation play equally crucial roles in shaping these beliefs.
The Impact of Elite Messaging on Public Perception
The rise of conspiracy theories in modern politics is heavily influenced by elite narratives, particularly those propagated by political figures like Donald Trump. His appeals to anti-establishment sentiments have mobilized segments of the electorate that previously lacked a voice within traditional party structures. Consequently, this political coalition is especially susceptible to conspiratorial thinking as they are primed to distrust mainstream narratives. Understanding this shift requires a nuanced examination of how elite messaging intersects with grassroots beliefs, further complicating the relationship between conspiracy theory and partisanship.
Are conspiracy theories more popular than ever? Are Americans more conspiratorial than ever? Are conservatives more conspiratorial than liberals? Joseph Uscinski is a political scientist at the University of Miami and one of the nation's preeminent experts on the psychology of conspiratorial thinking and the history of conspiracy theories in America. He has some counterintuitive and surprising answers to these questions. Today, he and Derek discuss—and debate—the psychology and politics of modern conspiratorial thinking.
If you have questions, observations, or ideas for future episodes, email us at PlainEnglish@Spotify.com.
