Shameless Popery

#226 Why The Book of Mormon is America’s Quran

Nov 20, 2025
The discussion explores the controversial argument that the Book of Mormon and Quran can only be divine given the supposed limitations of their authors, Joseph Smith and Muhammad. Joe critiques this notion, highlighting that dismissing their intellect is both condescending and strategically flawed. He examines the high literacy levels in 19th-century America, offers insights into the oral culture's memory capacities, and cites Joseph Smith’s coherent writing skills. Ultimately, he challenges listeners to reconsider the literary argument's validity.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Literary Argument Is Not Proof

  • The "too dumb to write it" argument claims Joseph Smith and Muhammad lacked education to author their texts.
  • Joe Heschmeyer says this literary argument alone doesn't prove divine origin and is not convincing.
INSIGHT

Mutually Exclusive Conclusions Collapse Argument

  • The same "can't-be-manmade" logic supports both the Quran and the Book of Mormon, yet they conflict.
  • Heschmeyer argues that this mutual exclusivity shows the argument is flawed by reductio ad absurdum.
ADVICE

Don't Answer With Condescension

  • Avoid responding to these claims with condescension or scoffing.
  • Heschmeyer advises Christians to engage charitably since insults strengthen the opposing case.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app